Best Puppy Training Treats 2020 – Reviews & Top Picks 

Nulo Puppy & Adult Freestyle Trainers Dog Treats

Training treats can be a great reward for positive reinforcement training, but there are many brands available that claim to be the best.

While some treats may be tasty to your dog, they could be filled with low-quality ingredients. It’s important to review each product carefully before you decide.

Thankfully, we’ve done the hard work for you and found the best training treats. We tested and reviewed each product, so you don’t have to.

Here are the 10 Best Puppy Training Treats and their reviews:

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats
  • Small size perfect for training
  • All-natural ingredients
  • Fortified with vitamins & minerals
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Wellness Grain-Free Puppy Treats Wellness Grain-Free Puppy Treats
  • Made with real lamb & salmon
  • Easy-to-chew soft shape
  • Strong flavor without smell
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Blue Buffalo Soft-Moist Dog Treats Blue Buffalo Soft-Moist Dog Treats
  • Made with high-quality ingredients
  • No artificial colors or flavors
  • Convenient training size treats
  • Pet Botanics Training Treats Pet Botanics Training Treats
  • Made with real meat & supplements
  • Small training-size treats
  • Easy to chew for smaller puppies
  • Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats
  • No by-products or preservatives
  • Free of corn, soy and wheat
  • Soft texture for easier eating
  • The 10 Best Puppy Training Treats

    1. Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats – Best Overall

    Old Mother Hubbard

    If you’re looking for the best puppy training treats, Old Mother Hubbard 10237 Natural Dog Treats are a healthy and tasty addition to your pup’s diet. Old Mother Hubbard treats are bite-sized biscuits that are great for training your new puppy. This brand is made with all-natural ingredients fortified with vitamins and minerals essential for your dog. Old Mother Hubbard treats have little to no smell, so you won’t have stinky hands after training sessions. The only issue is that this brand is made with wheat, so it’s not suitable for dogs with wheat allergies. Otherwise, we find Old Mother Hubbard Natural Dog Treats to be the best overall puppy training treat.

    Pros
    • Small size perfect for training
    • All-natural ingredients
    • Fortified with vitamins & minerals
    • Little to no smell
    Cons
    • Contains wheat

    2. Wellness Grain-Free Puppy Treats – Best Value

    Wellness Natural Pet Food

    Wellness 89614 Grain Free Puppy Training Treats are high-quality training treats with a blend of real lamb and salmon, as well as other fresh fruits and vegetables. These treats are soft and easy to chew, so you don’t have to worry about your new puppy struggling to eat them. The strong flavor is popular with most dogs, and it doesn’t have a strong smell. These biscuits don’t have any fillers like corn, wheat or soy, but it does contain a preservative and that’s why we kept it out of our #1 spot. However, Wellness Puppy Training treats have a lot of health benefits that make them a very popular treat. If you’re looking for the best value, Wellness 89614 Grain Free Puppy Training Treats are the best puppy training treats for the money.

    Pros
    • Made with real lamb & salmon
    • Easy-to-chew soft shape
    • Strong flavor without smell
    • No corn, wheat & soy
    Cons
    • Contains a preservative

    3. Blue Buffalo Soft-Moist Dog Treats – Premium Choice

    Blue Buffalo

    If you’re looking for premium puppy training dog treat, Blue Buffalo 801858 Soft-Moist Training Dog Treats are made with high-quality, all-natural ingredients. Blue Buffalo is a soft and moist treat with vitamins and minerals, with no artificial colors or flavors that could be bad for your puppy’s health. This brand also comes in convenient little bites for a quick and easy training treat.

    The flavor of Blue Buffalo treats may be a bit rich for some puppies, so these treats may not be suitable for your puppy. Another issue is that this brand does have a strong smell, and it will transfer onto your fingers. Blue Buffalo is also on the expensive side of puppy treats, which kept it out of our Top 2 spots. If you don’t mind the smell and are looking for premium brand treats, Blue Buffalo 801858 Soft-Moist Training Dog Treats are a great option.

    Pros
    • Made with high-quality ingredients
    • No artificial colors or flavors
    • Convenient training size treats
    Cons
    • Rich flavor can upset stomach
    • Strong smell
    • On the expensive side

    4. Pet Botanics 78304 Training Treats

    Pet Botanics

    Pet Botanics 78304 Training Treats are made from real mean and vitamins, with no artificial ingredients or fillers for a quick and convenient treat for your puppy. This brand is made with real meat and supplements, but the smell is strong and slightly unpleasant. The bite-sized treats are great for training and are easy-to-chew for smaller dogs and puppies. However, some picky dogs didn’t like this brand, so we recommend trying other brands if your puppy is fussy. Also, Pet Botanics contains botanical ingredients that can lead to indigestion, so they’re not suitable for dogs or puppies with sensitive stomachs.

    Pros
    • Made with real meat & supplements
    • Small training-size treats
    • Easy to chew for smaller puppies
    Cons
    • Strong, unpleasant smell
    • Picky dogs may refuse them
    • Botanical ingredients may cause indigestion

    5. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats

    Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats

    Blue Buffalo BLU10130 Wilderness Trail Treats are a soft-style training treat for puppies and dogs with no ingredients like preservatives or byproducts. Blue Buffalo uses a recipe free of corn, soy, and wheat, so they’ll work for dogs with food allergies. These training treats have a soft texture that is easy for smaller dogs and puppies to chew. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Treats are on the expensive side compared to other treats, so they may not be the best value for you. These treats also have a certain flavor that may not be suitable for picky eaters, so don’t be surprised if your puppy isn’t going crazy over them. The main issue is that Blue Buffalo Wilderness contains liquid smoke, a flavoring with controversial data over its safety. For a better value and tastier product, we recommend trying Old Mother Hubbard treats first.

    Pros
    • No by-products or preservatives
    • Free of corn, soy and wheat
    • Soft texture for easier eating
    Cons
    • Expensive compared to other treats
    • Not suitable for picky eaters
    • Contains liquid smoke

    6. Hill’s 1879 Dog Training Treats

    Hills Dog Treats

    Hill’s 1879 Dog Training Treats are a small training treat made with real chicken, which is the first ingredient. These treats are low-calorie treats for longer training sessions, and they’re bite-sized for convenience. Unfortunately, Hill’s Dog Training Treats are harder to chew than other brand treats, so they’re not the best option for small dogs and puppies. Hill’s also contains wheat products, as well as other questionable ingredients like smoke flavor. Lastly, the portion is really small compared to other brands, so this option will become expensive for bigger puppies. We recommend trying (#1) for better quality or (#2) for a better value.

    Pros
    • Chicken is first ingredient
    • Low-calorie treat
    • Bite-sized for training
    Cons
    • Harder to chew than other brands
    • Contains wheat and smoke flavor
    • Small portion for the price

    7. Zuke’s Puppy Naturals Dog Treats

    Zuke

    Zuke’s 33084 Puppy Naturals Dog Treats is a high-protein training treat made with salmon and potatoes for a tasty treat. This brand uses all-natural ingredients, with no mysterious ingredients, fillers or preservatives. Zuke’s Puppy Treats also contain vitamins A, C, and E for extra wellness support for your puppy. Some dogs refused to eat these treats, while the weird smell may also deter you away from buying them again. Also, Zuke’s Puppy Naturals are a hard texture, which can be difficult for your puppy to chew. For a healthier, tastier snack and a better value, we recommend trying other brands first.

    Pros
    • High-protein treat
    • No fillers or preservatives
    • Made with Vitamins A, C & E
    Cons
    • Weird smell
    • Harder texture than other brands
    • Picky dogs may refuse them

    8. Lil’ Bitz Smoked Beef Training Treats

    Lil Bitz

    Lil’ Bitz Hickory Smoked Beef Training Treats are little chewy training treats made with all-natural ingredients. While the quality is high and this brand is less expensive compared to most treats, most dogs simply don’t like the flavor of these. Even dogs that do eat them don’t seem to be excited over them compared to other treats. Lil’ Bitz Beef Treats also have a strong odor to them, and it’ll stay on your skin even after washing your hands. The texture of Lil’ Bitz is sticky and may be difficult for your puppy to chew.

    Pros
    • Beef is first ingredient
    • Less expensive than other treats
    • All-natural ingredients
    Cons
    • Most dogs don’t like the flavor
    • Strong odor that stays on hands
    • Very sticky texture

    9. Nulo Puppy Trainers Dog Treats

    Nulo

    Nulo 56TS04 Puppy Trainers Dog Treats are a small training treat made with all-natural salmon and minerals. They’re lower in calories compared to other training treat brands, so they won’t cause excess weight gain in your puppy. Nulo Trainers Dog Treats are small in size, so they’re safe for puppies and small dogs. The main issue with Nulo is that these treats have a bad smell that’s pretty strong. This brand is lacking in flavor and some dogs did not like the taste of these at all. The texture is also oddly dry and flaky as if they’re old or stale. Nulo Puppy Treats are also more expensive, without the quality of premium brands.

    Pros
    • Lower in calories than other brands
    • Small bites for puppies and small dogs
    Cons
    • Bad, strong smell
    • Some dogs may not like the taste
    • Dry and flaky texture
    • On the expensive side

    10. Buddy Biscuits Soft & Chewy Treats

    Buddy Biscuits

    Buddy Biscuits 18103 Soft & Chewy Training Treats are small chicken flavored treats made with a soft texture that is safe for puppies and small dogs to chew and eat. This brand is a low-calorie brand of treat, so there’s no concern about weight gain from using these while you train your pup.

    However, there are a few concerns that we have with Buddy Biscuits Training Treats that outweigh the benefits. One problem is that these treats contain preservatives, which are controversial food additives with unknown health effects. Another issue is that they’re made with oats and flour, which are not suitable for puppies with allergies. Also, this brand has a strange taste and a very strong odor, which some dogs will turn down.

    For better taste and high-quality ingredients, we recommend trying other puppy training treats first.

    Pros
    • Soft texture safe for puppies
    • Low-calorie treat
    Cons
    • Made with oats and flour
    • Contains preservatives
    • Some dogs refused to eat
    • Stronger odor than most brands

    Buyer’s Guide

    Important things to consider

    There are important things to factor into your decision when buying puppy training treats. Your dog’s size, health, activity level, and diet are all things to take into consideration. Other factors like cost, flavor, and smell are other things that may influence your decision.

    What Makes a Good Training Treat?

    A good training treat for your puppy will have a good source of protein, a savory flavor your puppy will love, and high-quality ingredients. Avoid buying treats with filler ingredients such as corn and soy. A good training treat will also be small and low in calories for longer training sessions, so look for treats that are little and less than five calories each.

    Types of Training Treats

    There are many types of training treats, with soft-bite, biscuit, and freeze-dried being the most popular types of treats. Each type has its own benefits, but it’s important to find one that fits your dog’s diet. Consider each type and brand, and always look out for any negative reactions.

    Conclusion

    After careful research and reviews, we found Old Mother Hubbard 10237 Natural Dog Treats to be the best overall puppy training treat. They’re all-natural and full of flavor, without the smell that most treats come with. For best value, Wellness 89614 Grain Free Puppy Training Treats are high-quality without the premium price tag. They’re easy and soft for your puppy to chew, too.

    Hopefully, we have made shopping for puppy training treats an easier task for you. We looked for the best products on the market and gave our honest reviews of each. When in doubt, talk to your veterinarian for what will work best for your dog.


    By Jaimie Hannon

    Featured image credit: Nulo Puppy & Adult Freestyle Trainers Dog Treats, Amazon