Best Plush Dog Toys 2020 – Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated:

Dog Toy-HuggleHounds-Amazon

Dogs love spending time with their humans, but they love their toys, too. What they love even more is engaging in interactive play with both. Your dog probably already has a vast selection of toys like stuffed animals, squeakers, and chew bones.

They probably have their favorites, just like children. But that doesn’t mean they want to stop adding to their collection. If they are a fan of plush toys but also rip them up over time with intense play, you are probably looking for replacements that will stretch your dollar.

If your dog loves plushies, you may want to buy them a durable toy that is worth the money you pay and serves its purpose efficiently. When it comes to safety, durability, and design, we took the liberty of compiling reviews of our top 10 favorites.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites 

ModelPriceDesignEditor Rating
Outward Hound
Outward Hound 31004 Plush Dog Toy
(Best Overall)

Check Price
Squirrel4.75/5
Multipet
Multipet 48375 Plush Dog Toy
(Best Value)

Check Price
Lambchop4.65/5
Nocciola Squeaky
Nocciola Dog Squeaky PlushToys
(Premium Choice)

Check Price
Mixed4.50/5
ZippyPaws Squeaky
ZippyPaws ZP059 Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

Check Price
Mixed4.20/5
goDog
goDog 774019 Plush Dog Toy

Check Price
Alligator3.75/5

The 10 Best Plush Dog Toys – Reviews 2020 

1. Outward Hound Plush Dog Toy – Best Overall

Outward Hound 31004 Plush Dog Toy

The Outward Hound 31004 Plush Dog Toy is our favorite, making it the number one pick for us. It’s an adorable design, having little squirrels poking out of a tree trunk. It’s ultra-soft but has a highly durable feel. It’s well-stitched and is made from a thicker plush material so you won’t have to worry about it your dog ripping it open right away.

The squirrels are detachable, so you can take them out and stuff them into the holes of the tree trunks, or your dog can treat it like a puzzle and pull them out over and over. It can serve well for long periods of entertainment and fun. Each squirrel has a squeaker inside, so they will be even more enticed to seek them out. It’s great not only for having a chew toy but for mental stimulation, as well.

It may not be able to withstand the force of avid and determined chewers. If they chew it open, they can ingest stuffing and the internal components, so be careful if your dog is hellbent on destroying any toy they come across.

Pros
  • Brain stimulator
  • Squeakers for chewing
  • Cute design
  • Durable plush
Cons
  • Not for heavy chewers

2. Multipet Plush Dog Toy – Best Value

Multipet 48375 Plush Dog Toy

This Multipet 48375 Plush Dog Toy is one of the most adorable additions to the list, and the most affordable. This is one of the best plush dog toys for the money. Lambchop is a character almost every child from the 1960s grew up loving. While this isn’t a puppet, it is a fantastic squeaker toy your dog can enjoy, and so can you—if you’re feeling a bit nostalgic. 

Even if you don’t know who Lambchop is, you can’t deny this soft little toy is cute and capable for your pet. They will spend hours playing, tossing, and fetching this character. It may be a new dog bed favorite in no time. It is 10 inches, so it’s a nice size as well.

If you have an aggressive chewer, be careful. The internal components of this toy could be potentially dangerous if swallowed. Since it is a thinner material, it wouldn’t take long for a dog to rip it up if they decided they wanted to. Use with supervision if you are unsure of how well your dog will treat it.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Decent size
  • Potential sentimental memories
  • Very soft
Cons
  • Internal components dangerous if swallowed

3. Nocciola Dog Squeaky PlushToys – Premium Choice

Nocciola Dog Squeaky PlushToys

This Nocciola Dog Squeaky Plush Toy is our number three only because it is slightly pricier than others we found, but we still think it’s a fantastic pick. The reason for this is likely because it’s made of reinforced fabric, having two plush layers for added durability. Its real wool, as well, making it more realistic for your pet.

You can choose from five different creatures, and each of them is between 18 and 22 inches. These toys are also not filled with stuffing, so you don’t have to worry about your dog swallowing it. There are two squeakers inside; one in the head, the other in the tail—so your dog can have fun on both ends.

While the outside is very sturdy, the squeakers may not hold up as well. They may deflate with tough chewing or rough play. But if you’re looking to keep your dog entertained with a more impenetrable plush toy, it may be worth the extra expense.

Pros
  • Reinforced fabric
  • Real wool
  • No stuffing or harmful parts
  • Two squeakers
Cons
  • More expensive
  • Squeakers may wear down

4. ZippyPaws Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

ZippyPaws ZP059 Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

With the ZippyPaws ZP059 Squeaky Plush Dog Toy, you can have the no-stuffing option at a lower price. There are three different sizing selections so that you can choose the best size for your dog. You can also decide between the fox, raccoon, or squirrel to give your dog their favorite woodland surprise.

There are three squeakers inside, evenly placed down the body. These materials are not reinforced, so while they don’t have stuffing inside, they may not hold up against dogs who love to destroy their toys. The internal squeakers may come out as well, posing as a choking hazard.

But if your dog loves playing tug-of-war, this can be a stimulating toy for them. Supervision is advised if you do buy for a dog who loves to chew. The last thing you want is a vet visit because they swallow something they shouldn’t.

Pros
  • Cute design choices
  • Various sizes
  • No stuffing
Cons
  • Squeakers may pose choking hazard
  • Not as durable

5. goDog Plush Dog Toy

goDog 774019 Plush Dog Toy

The goDog 774019 Plush Dog Toy is an adorable addition to the list. It’s available in two sizes so you can select the one that your dog could use the most. It also has a few bright color selections to stimulate play and make it easy for your dog to find.

They made this plush toy to last. It has double stitching to reinforce durability. While it does have stuffing, it is very light in comparison to toy size, so it is still able to flail around. This encourages your pet to thrash and play, which is both mentally and physically stimulating.

It has what goDog refers to as Chew Guard Technology, making the squeaker and overall design safe from consequences of rough treatment. However, dogs who are more prone to tearing up their toys may conquer this gator with moderate force. So, take your pet’s play style into consideration.

Pros
  • Colorful
  • Double-stitching
  • Chew Guard Technology
Cons
  • Comes apart with moderate force

6. HuggleHounds Plush Dog Toy

HuggleHounds 10693 Plush Dog Toy

These HuggleHounds 10693 Plush Dog Toys come in multiple different character choices. They also have sizes large and small. These darling little plushies are made to look like corduroy and are knotted at the knees and elbows. The floppy arms and legs keep playtime enticing, allowing them to shake it around and give it a good chewing.

The material is also washable, so if your pet slobbers on it a bit too much or drags it until it’s dirty—it won’t matter. You just throw it into the wash and hang it up to dry quickly.

The only downside to this item is that the dangling arms may easily tear. Because they are simply pieces of material, it can be an easy place for chewers to rip at it, leading to a limbless toy. Because it’s one of the more expensive choices on our list, it may not be worth the price for a destructive dog.

Pros
  • Many different choices
  • Different designs
  • Machine washable
Cons
  • Limbs can come apart

7. Pet Qwerks Dog Squeak Plush Toys

Pet Qwerks P173 Dog Squeak Plush Toys

Pet Qweks P173 Dog Squeak Plush Toys have a wide-character selection for no-stuffing, mess-free fun. They’re charming but also quite tiny. If you have a small to medium-sized dog or one who isn’t a heavy chewer, this choice may work wonders for your dog.

The material is a bit thin, so it seems it could likely fall apart easily with rough play. If you have a dog who just likes to squeak or fetch the toy, it could help your pet have many hours of fun. There is one large squeaker in the middle of it.

If you find that this puppy plushie just doesn’t work with your pet, Pet Qwerks makes returning a breeze. So, if you decide to purchase, you can get ahold of the company to make it right.

Pros
  • Cute designs
  • Large squeaker
Cons
  • Thin material
  • Not for heavy chewers

8. Rocco & Roxie Plush Squeak Toy

Rocco & Roxie Plush Squeak Toy

These dinosaur-shaped corduroy style Rocco & Roxie Plush Squeak Toys are sure to provide lots of entertainment for your pup. You can choose from the adorable brontosaurus, triceratops, or vulture. The materials have no chemicals or added dyes—advertised as being 100% eco-friendly. This way, your dog can have fun playing without worries.

This selection does have stuffing and crinkly paper for sound effects. While this can make playtime a ball for your dog, if you have one who can rip holes in all their toys, you may be cleaning up fluffy messes.

Overall, this is a very decent size, ideal for multiple breeds. The designs are delightful. If you love the way these ones look and think your pet will enjoy them as well, you should try it out.

Pros
  • Eco-friendly
  • Excellent size for multiple breeds
  • Adorable designs
Cons
  • Includes stuffing

9. EXPAWLORER Dog Plush Toys

EXPAWLORER DT003-OCTOPUS01 Dog Plush Toys

If your dog really enjoys toys that flop around like crazy, the EXAWLORER DT003-OCTOPUS01 Dog Plush Toy may make them very happy pups. With eight long legs of plushie fun, they can sling this cute octopus around. It’s even perfect for two dogs to play a good game of tug-of-war.

It’s made of polyester material that feels extremely soft. Both color choices are vivid, so your pets can easily remember to play with them. The plush head is full of cotton material, not traditional stuffing. It’s 17 inches in length and recommended for small to medium breeds.

Because of the long legs and overall design, it would be easy for dogs to pull apart if they wanted to. If you have an aggressive chewer or a rowdy pair of dogs, this may not hold up long.

Pros
  • Long legs great for games
  • Fun for two dogs
Cons
  • Rips easily
  • Not for large dogs
  • Not for aggressive chewers

10. LEGEND SANDY Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

LEGEND SANDY Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

This LEGEND SANDY Squeaky Plush Dog Toy 12-pack is our final pick. They come with all different cutesy animal characters with squeakers included. They are specifically designed for puppies and small breeds of dogs. The company is quite transparent about the fact that these are not indestructible, so don’t mistakenly order these for an aggressive chewer or large dog.

These toys can be stored in the drawstring bag they came with upon shipping. They aren’t glued together, but hand-stitched for better quality. However, some of them have loose threads, which can come undone with minimal force. Do be careful and inspect each toy before handing them over to your little guy or gal.

They can be machine-washed or washed by hand, so you can keep these nice and clean. While they may not be ideal for bigger pets, they are fantastic learning toys for puppies. Please give with caution, as puppies can potentially choke if they rip the squeakers out. Legend Sandy also has a 30-day refund or replacement guarantee.

Pros
  • Great for puppies
  • Value pack
Cons
  • Not for a medium breeder or bigger
  • Potential choking hazard
  • Loose stitching

Conclusion

After looking over these reviews, hopefully, one has snagged your attention. We still stand by our number one pick. The Outward Hound 31004 Plush Dog Toy provides mental stimulation, exercise, and focus for your dog. It’s also interactive since you are the one who will have to put back the squeaky squirrels for your dog. They will have a ton of fun, and you probably will, too!

The classic Lambchop design of the Multipet 48375 Plush Dog Toy will keep your dog busy. It may also turn into their favorite dog bed sleepy time toy. It’s the favorite on our list for being the most affordable while still providing you with adequate quality. 

Lastly, the Nocciola Dog Squeaky Plush Toy is reinforced with wool fabric for a realistic feel and optimal play. It’s very well put together, so even a dog who tough chewer may have trouble ripping it to shreds. It may be the more expensive selection on the top ten, but it could certainly be worth your money.

But that doesn’t mean any of our other picks wouldn’t be just as perfect for your pooch. No matter your choice, your dog will be sure to love it.


Featured Image: Dog Toy/HuggleHounds, Amazon