Best Indoor Dog Potty 2020 – Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated:

PetSafe PWM00-14499Whether you have a puppy or an older dog, an indoor dog potty can be an invaluable addition to your home. You’ll be able to prevent accidents, work on training, and comfortably leave your dog at home while you work. But there are several types and even more brands, so which dog potty should you buy?

To help you choose the best indoor dog potty, we bought and tested quite a few models. The result is this list of the 10 best indoor dog potties available in 2020. For each model, we’ve written a detailed review, comparing price, design, durability, ease of cleaning, size, and warranty so you can make a well-informed decision. And if you’re still wondering which model to choose, take a look at our buyer’s guide, which will further explain your options. Keep reading to find your dog’s new indoor potty!


A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

ModelPriceSizes AvailableEditor Rating
PETMAKER Artificial Grass
small PETMAKER Artificial Grass(Best Overall)

Check Price
2 Sizes4.70/5
SavvyGrow Artificial Grass
small SavvyGrow Artificial Grass(Best Value)

Check Price
8 Sizes4.50/5
PetSafe Potty
small PetSafe Potty(Premium Choice)

Check Price
3 Sizes4.45/5
Fresh Patch Potty
small Fresh Patch Potty

Check Price
3 Sizes3.70/5
DoggieLawn Potty
small DoggieLawn Potty

Check Price
2 Sizes3.60/5

The 10 Best Indoor Dog Potties – Reviews 2020

1. PETMAKER Grass Portable Potty Trainer – Best Overall

PETMAKER 80-ST2025

Our overall favorite model is the PETMAKER 80-ST2025 Artificial Grass Portable Potty Trainer, which is a well-priced, artificial grass potty with an effective, easy to clean collection tray.

This 4.1-pound potty comes in two sizes and has an odor-resistant, antimicrobial synthetic grass mat. A plastic insert separates this mat from the large collection tray, which is simple to empty and hand-wash with soapy water. This potty is fairly large, with dimensions of 20 by 25 inches, and is designed for indoor and outdoor use, including porches and patios. Replacement mats are readily available through PETMAKER.

When we tested this potty, we found that it worked well and was reasonably durable. The grass may come apart if your dog is a strong chewer, and the mat doesn’t attach to the plastic insert. This potty can quickly become smelly and needs frequent cleaning. PETMAKER offers a great satisfaction guarantee.

Pros
  • Fairly-priced and sold in two sizes
  • Odor-resistant, antimicrobial synthetic grass mat with replacements available
  • Large, easy to clean collection tray
  • Designed for indoor and outdoor use
  • Satisfaction guarantee
Cons
  • Grass doesn’t hold up to chewing
  • Mat doesn’t attach to tray or insert
  • Becomes smelly quickly and requires frequent cleaning

2. SavvyGrow Grass Puppy Potty – Best Value

SavvyGrow

If you’re interested in saving money, you may want to look at the SavvyGrow Artificial Grass Puppy Potty, which we found to be the best indoor dog potty for the money.

This multifunctional artificial grass is inexpensive and comes in a wide range of sizes, from 17 by 24 inches up to five by 15 feet. Conveniently, you can trim this grass to fit your space. It’s weather-proof and looks convincingly like grass. There’s also a non-slip rubber back, and the grass is made of non-toxic polyethylene and polypropylene.

This grass is well designed for outdoor use, with many drain holes but no catching tray. To use it inside or on a balcony, you’ll need to supply an absorbent pad or collection tray. This grass also gets hot quickly in the sun and may shed quite a bit. SavvyGrow doesn’t offer a warranty.

Pros
  • Inexpensive and convincingly grass-like
  • Multifunctional artificial grass sold in many sizes
  • Easy to customize for different spaces
  • Weather-proof and durable with a non-slip rubber back
  • Non-toxic with many drain holes
Cons
  • May shed frequently
  • No warranty
  • Gets hot quickly in the sun
  • Needs pad or collection tray for indoor or balcony use

Why is your dog eating grass? Click here to find out!


3. PetSafe Portable Indoor Dog Potty – Premium Choice

PetSafe PWM00-14499

If you’re in the market for a high-end model, you may want to consider the PetSafe PWM00-14499 Portable Indoor Dog Potty, which is pricey and heavy but offers effective odor-reducing features.

This dog potty weighs a hefty 12 pounds and comes in three sizes, ranging from 21 to 33 inches long. It features a thin artificial grass mat, a slanted channeling tray, and a collection bin with a removable Pee Pod liner. The package includes a liner, four grass mat clips, and a urine and odor absorber that turns urine into a solid gel for easy, odor-free disposal.

This model is somewhat more complicated to use, and the high price is compounded by the fact that you’ll have to keep buying liners and absorbing liquid. Though the grass mat clips on, it falls off easily, and the channeling tray isn’t strong enough to accommodate larger dogs. PetSafe offers a one-year warranty.

Pros
  • Choice of three large sizes
  • Artificial grass and collection bin with a removable liner
  • Includes a liner, four grass mat clips, and absorbing liquid
  • Urine and odor absorber makes for easy, odorless disposal
  • One-year warranty
Cons
  • Expensive, heavy, and requires repeated purchases
  • More complicated
  • Grass matt falls off easily
  • Channeling tray isn’t very durable

 


4. Fresh Patch Disposable Dog Potty

Fresh Patch

The Fresh Patch Disposable Dog Potty is a real dirt-free grass option that may be expensive over time and is best suited to small dogs and puppies.

This dog potty comes in three sizes up to 24 inches long. The grass is hydroponically grown in California and intended to be replaced every one to two weeks. It comes in a cardboard box that doubles as a collection tray.

As a disposable dog potty, this model is fairly expensive. It’s designed for dogs weighing up to 30 pounds, so it won’t work well for large dogs. We also found that this grass sometimes arrived with bugs and the cardboard collection tray leaked over time. There isn’t a warranty.

Pros
Cons
  • Doesn’t work as well for large dogs
  • May be expensive over time
  • May arrive with bugs
  • Collection tray leaks over time
  • No warranty

5. DoggieLawn Real Grass Dog Potty

DoggieLawn

DoggieLawn’s 8MRW Real Grass Dog Potty is another disposable real grass option that is smaller and may leak.

This 10-pound dog potty comes in two small sizes, 20 and 16 inches long. The real grass, which has a somewhat absorbent dirt liner, is designed to be replaced every two weeks. DoggieLawn offers free dog training assistance, and the package includes a pheromone spray to encourage your dog’s potty use.

When we tested this dog potty, we found that it was very small and didn’t work for larger dogs. The dirt liner is messy and the potty may leak quickly or arrive with bugs. This disposable potty may also be expensive over time. DoggieLawn doesn’t offer a warranty.

Pros
  • Disposable real grass with dirt liner
  • Lasts two weeks
  • Free dog training assistance and pheromone spray
  • Somewhat absorbent dirt liner and choice of two sizes
Cons
  • May be expensive over time
  • Doesn’t work well for larger dogs
  • Messy and may leak or arrive with bugs
  • No warranty

6. Blyss Pets Paws Indoor Dog Potty

Blyss Pets

The Blyss Pets Klean Paws Indoor Dog Potty is a lightweight plastic model that can be hard to clean but works with disposable pads.

This reasonably-priced dog potty weighs two pounds and has a perforated plastic grate that securely attaches to a collection tray. There are non-slip rubber pads on the bottom, and you can put disposable pads inside the tray.

We liked the snap-on grate, which effectively kept dogs from the collection tray. However, the grid is only 18 by 14 inches and is too flimsy to support larger dogs. Solid stool can be particularly difficult to clean off of the grate, resulting in an unsanitary potty. The plastic also has an unpleasant chemical smell and Blyss Pets doesn’t offer a warranty.

Pros
  • Lightweight and fairly-priced
  • Perforated plastic grate attaches securely to the collection tray
  • Compatible with disposable pads
  • Non-slip rubber coating
Cons
  • Small, flimsy grate won’t work for larger dogs
  • Solid stool is particularly difficult to clean
  • Unpleasant chemical smell
  • No warranty

7. Simple Solution Washable Puppy Pad

Simple Solution

Simple Solution’s 11443 Washable Puppy Pad is inexpensive, versatile, and easy to clean. Unfortunately, it’s not very effective and may leak or smell.

This 1.75-pound puppy pad comes in a low-cost two-pack. The pads, which have a fun paw-print pattern, are 30 by 32 inches and are conveniently machine-washable. They have sturdy double stitching and four layers, including a moisture-wicking top sheet and a non-slip waterproof bottom. You can use these fast-absorbing pads as crate or kennel liners, car pads, or food mats.

We found that these pads weren’t absorbent enough and tended to leak over time. They also hold smells, even after washing, and don’t feel durable enough to last a long time. Simple Solution doesn’t offer a warranty.

Pros
  • Low-cost, reusable fabric pads with fun patterns
  • Fairly large and machine-washable
  • Four layers, with moisture-wicking, non-slip, and waterproof features
  • Fast-absorbing and versatile
Cons
  • Not very absorbent and may leak
  • Become smelly quickly
  • Not especially durable
  • No warranty

8. Prevue Pet Products Tinkle Turf

Prevue Pet

The Prevue Pet Products 501 Tinkle Turf is a lightweight, moderately-priced synthetic grass model with a collection tray. It’s also not very well designed and somewhat hard to clean.

This 2.3-pound dog potty comes in several sizes and features a synthetic grass top layer with antimicrobial odor control and flow-through backing. The collection pan is lead-free and fairly large.

We found this artificial grass cheap-feeling and not very durable. The grass layer sits directly in the collection tray, making it less sanitary, and doesn’t attach securely, so your dog will be able to pull it off. The potty must also be hand-washed frequently and can be difficult to thoroughly clean. Prevue doesn’t offer a warranty.

Pros
  • Lightweight and moderately-priced
  • Antimicrobial synthetic grass with flow-through backing
  • Large, lead-free collection tray
Cons
  • Cheap-feeling, less durable artificial grass that doesn’t attach to tray
  • Less sanitary design
  • Can be difficult to clean
  • No warranty

9. STARROAD-TIM Artificial Grass Rug Turf

 

STARROAD-TIM

The STARROAD-TIM Artificial Grass Rug Turf is an inexpensive, lightweight synthetic grass option that doesn’t come with a collection tray and can’t hold up to chewing or digging.

This low-cost 2.01-pound dog potty measures a generous 39.3 by 31.5 inches. The synthetic grass is attached to a rubber pad, which you can easily trim to fit your space. This potty is weatherproof and non-toxic, with drain holes and rubber gaskets.

When we tested this synthetic grass, we found that it didn’t feel very high-quality and shed quite a bit. It doesn’t feel sturdy overall. Without a collection tray, it won’t work as well inside or on a balcony. To keep it from smelling, you’ll want to hand-wash this model frequently. This model comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee for refund or replacement.

Pros
  • Low-cost and lightweight
  • Large rubber pad with synthetic grass
  • Easy to customize the shape
  • Weatherproof and non-toxic, with drain holes and rubber gaskets
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
Cons
  • Less suited to indoor or balcony use
  • Lower-quality synthetic grass sheds quickly
  • No collection tray
  • Needs frequent hand-washing

10. Fortune-star Grass Mat Indoor Potty

Fortune-star

Our least favorite dog potty is the Fortune-star Artificial Grass Dog Mat Indoor Potty, which is a large, inexpensive synthetic grass option that won’t work well indoors and begins to smell quickly.

This two-pound synthetic grass model, which is sold at a very low price, features drainage holes and a non-slip rubber layer. It’s non-toxic, lead-free, and mildew-resistant, and measures a large 39.3 by 31.5 inches. You can easily cut this pad to fit into your home.

We found this model less durable and cheap-feeling. The black liner begins to shred immediately, and the pad holds onto odors. There isn’t a collection tray, and you’ll need to hand-wash this dog potty regularly. Fortune-star offers a good 100% satisfaction guarantee.

Pros
  • Inexpensive, large, and lightweight
  • Easy to trim for your home
  • Synthetic grass with non-slip rubber and drainage holes
  • Non-toxic, lead-free, and mildew-resistant
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
Cons
  • Less durable and somewhat cheap-feeling
  • Black liner shreds easily
  • Holds onto odors
  • No collection tray
  • Needs frequent hand-washing

Buyer’s Guide

You’ve read through our list of the best indoor dog potties. But you’ll want to make sure you’re buying a great model, so which indoor potty will work best for you, your dog, and your wallet? Keep reading for our comprehensive guide to your options.

What are the different types?

What type of dog potty you choose will depend on your dog’s needs. Are you looking for a potty that will help you train your puppy, or do you need one for an adult dog while you’re at work?

Most indoor dog potties have a surface mat that lies on top of a collection tray. The collection tray is a key component because it will prevent leaks and hold your dog’s waste until you’re ready to empty it. You’ll want to pay attention to each model’s ease of cleaning and odor-reducing features, as these collection trays can quickly become smelly and leave your home with an unpleasant odor.

If you choose a model without a collection tray, you may want to supply your own or use disposable absorbent pads to contain the mess. Some of the models we reviewed aren’t as well-suited to indoor use because they can’t capture your dog’s waste.

The type of surface mat you choose will depend on your dog. There are three major types of potty mats: grass, plastic, and fabric.

Why choose a grass mat?

Grass mats can be a good choice because they approximate natural outdoor behavior. These mats can be synthetic or real. Synthetic grass mats can be rinsed and reused, making them a more cost-effective and sustainable choice. Often made of plastic with rubber backing, these artificial mats have drainage holes that will allow your dog’s urine to flow through to a collection tray or pad. You may want to look for a model with clips that will keep your artificial grass mat in place.

Real grass potties are real patches of grass typically shipped in cardboard boxes that double as collection trays. These potties are disposable and can be expensive over time, as you’ll need to replace them every few weeks. They can also be very effective training tools, teaching puppies, in particular, to seek out grass and avoid accidents on your floors. Real grass may also arrive with bugs in it, so you’ll probably want to check the package before you unwrap it.

Whether you choose synthetic or artificial grass, you’ll want to keep an eye on your dog to ensure that it doesn’t dig through or chew up the mat. Both types can be messy if chewed.

Why choose a plastic model?

Plastic indoor dog potties are typically made in grids that snap securely to underlying collection trays. These models are sturdier than grass options but can be too flimsy for heavier dogs. If you have a large dog, you may want to look closely at the recommended weight.

Plastic grids won’t help your dog associate grass with waste and may require additional training. They can also be less effective with solid waste, which may become stuck in the grid. These models can be difficult to fully clean and may become unsanitary over time.

 

Dog Indoor Potty Training

Why choose a fabric pad?

Absorbent fabric pads are versatile options and can make excellent liners for your dog’s crate, kennel, car seat, or food area. Many of these pads are machine-washable, which will minimize their odor retention, and have additional features like non-slip rubber backs, waterproof bottom layers, and sturdy double stitching.

Fabric pads can’t hold as much liquid as potties with collection trays and may not absorb quickly enough to keep your home or car clean. They are very lightweight and portable but may begin to smell over time.

Size

To decide what size of dog potty you’ll need, you’ll want to think about how large your dog is. If the potty is too small or flimsy to hold your dog, it may not want to use it. For the best results, you’ll probably want to choose a potty that will comfortably fit your dog. You may want to measure your dog and compare the numbers to your model’s mat or pat dimensions.

Warranty

Are you interested in the security of a good warranty? Though not all dog potties come with warranties, some offer satisfaction guarantees or one-year warranties. If you’re interested, look at the details of each warranty, and don’t forget to register your dog potty when it arrives.

Conclusion

What’s the bottom line? Our top pick is the PETMAKER 80-ST2025 Artificial Grass Portable Potty Trainer, which is an affordable synthetic grass model with an effective collection tray. Is your budget tight? You may want to look at the SavvyGrow Artificial Grass Puppy Potty, a synthetic grass option that offers great value and is easy to customize to your space. Are you interested in a high-end model? Take a look at the PetSafe PWM00-14499 Portable Indoor Dog Potty, a premium, feature-heavy option that’s odor-free and easy to clean.

Indoor dog potties can be incredibly convenient. They can help you train your dog and keep your home hygienic. But there are quite a few varieties available online, and you may not want to spend your time sorting through them. We hope this list of the 10 best indoor dog potties, complete with in-depth reviews and a full buyer’s guide, helps you choose a model that’s perfect for your dog and your home. A clean home and a happy dog are just a few clicks away!


Featured Image Credit By: PetSafe PWM00-14499, amazon