Chewy vs Amazon: Which Online Pet Store is Better?

chewy vs amazon

Being able to have dog food, toys, medicine, or anything else you need delivered directly to your door is something of a godsend, and today there are more online shops offering you that possibility than ever before.

Two of the largest are Amazon and Chewy. The former is an all-around Goliath, one of the biggest companies on the planet and a place where you can buy almost anything you can imagine. The latter is a relative newcomer, having been around only since 2011, and it specializes in pet food and accessories.

But which is better for pet owners, the do-everything store or the specialist? In the guide below, we examine that question in detail, so you can do business with the company that serves you best.

Divider 2

A Brief Overview of Amazon

As mentioned above, you can buy just about anything on Amazon, including every kind of device and contraption for dogs on the planet.

That’s certainly convenient, but it can also be overwhelming at times, especially because there are so many merchants on there — and they’re not all equally reputable. Amazon does a good job of policing the merchants and kicking off the scammers, but you never really know who you’re buying from.

divider 10

The feedback from fellow customers isn’t always trustworthy, either, as many sellers try to game the system by adding a ton of fake reviews. Amazon cracked down on that in recent years by adding the “Verified Purchase” setting, but determined scammers can still get around it.

However, it’s rare that you won’t be able to find what you’re looking for, and that comes in handy if your dog eats a specialty diet or if you’re hoping to find a toy he’s never tried (and destroyed) before.

Also, the company bends over backward to make sure that you’re satisfied, and returns are easy and painless.

Pros
  • Incredible selection
  • Good for finding rare or niche items
  • Company tries to police scammers
Cons
  • Selection can be overwhelming
  • Not all merchants are reputable
  • Filled with fake customer reviews

A Brief Overview of Chewy

Since Chewy is solely devoted to servicing pet owners, their entire store is built with your convenience in mind. You can choose to shop by category, pet type, or even brand.

This is undoubtedly useful, but it’s questionable how much effort it really saves you. After all, it doesn’t take much time to type the brand you’re looking for into Amazon’s search box (but leafing through all their results can be a pain).

Chewy Website
Chewy Website

Still, their categories (such as “large breed dog food” and the like) are better-curated than Amazon’s (who seems to rely on merchants to self-categorize). Chewy’s reviews are about as reliable as Amazon’s, although there are usually less of them.

Chewy also does what they can to make buying decisions easier, including keeping nutritional information front and center. Some items include feeding instructions and other tips, and there are instructional videos from experts on common topics like how to transition a pet to a new food.

One of the biggest advantages Chewy has is their pharmacy; you can simply mail in a prescription from your vet and get your pet’s prescription medication delivered to your door, often at a substantial discount. Amazon doesn’t yet offer this service, but it’s not necessarily something that every pet owner will avail themselves of.

Pros
  • Categories are well-curated
  • Lots of information to assist your decision-making
  • Has a pharmacy
Cons
  • Not much easier to navigate than Amazon
  • Fewer reviews than Amazon

Divider 8

Pricing

It’s difficult to give a one-size-fits-all answer to a category like pricing because there are so many variables involved (especially since Amazon has many merchants offering the same product at different prices).

Generally speaking, their prices are roughly the same (and both can underbid your local brick-and-mortar pet store by a fair amount). Both also tend to offer discounts if you sign up for their subscription services.

To give you a better idea of how the two services stack up against each other, we compared a few products on both of the sites.

Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Dry Dog Food (28 lb. bag)

Taste of the Wild

As you can see, both bags of this food cost the exact same at each site — down to the penny. However, if you sign up for Chewy’s subscription service, you can knock the price down by 5%, whereas Amazon’s price stays the same even if you subscribe.

Of course, there’s another price variable in play here: shipping. That deserves its own category, and we’ll get to it later.

Let’s look at the price of a toy now, shall we?

Outward Hound Interactive Hide-a-Squirrel Puzzle Toy (Ginormous)

Outward Hound

Again, both items are the same price (well, Chewy undercuts Amazon by a penny).

If you spend enough time looking, you’ll find certain items that have larger price disparities. By and large, however, the sticker price will be roughly the same at both places.

Divider 1

Shipping

This is one of the key differences between the two sites, but there are enough variables that it’s hard to give a blanket criticism of either site.

Chewy typically offers free shipping on any order over $49. That’s very useful, but only if you’re buying a high-end dog food or something like that. Otherwise, you’ll likely either find yourself paying for shipping or adding a bunch of extraneous items to your cart (thereby wasting money) to hit the $49 cap.

Amazon has many shipping options, on the other hand. You can pay as you go, or get free shipping once you reach $25. Another alternative is to sign up for Amazon Prime, which is $119 a year (or $59 a year for students).

If you have Amazon Prime, then all shipping costs are waived on two-day shipping. If you buy enough from the site, the service will eventually pay for itself.

As far as speed of shipping goes, both services are excellent, and you’ll usually receive your order within two business days.

divider 8

Returns

Returns are fairly easy with both services, although both have their own strengths and weaknesses.

Amazon generally has a 30-day return window. They don’t accept returns on pet foods, although they will usually give you store credit if you’re not satisfied. Also, the return process is fairly painless, with them providing you a variety of shipping options (as well as the necessary labels).

Chewy’s return policy is much more generous, although the actual act of returning items is more difficult. You have 365 days to return anything for any reason for a full refund (the only exception is prescription medication, unless there was an error with the order).

However, in order to send it back to the company, you’ll have to go through FedEx. This may or may not be an issue for you, depending on where you live, but it does limit your options.

Overall, most pet owners will probably find Chewy’s return policy to be superior to Amazon’s, but that’s less an indictment of Amazon than it is an endorsement of Chewy.

Dog pulling toy
Featured Image Credit: Josh Sorenson, Pexels

Customer Service

As you would probably expect from such huge websites, both have large customer support staff that works 24/7/365, and any questions or concerns you may have will likely be answered within 24 hours.

The employees at both places are friendly and easy to please, but both sites have a similar problem. If your issue requires you to ask multiple questions, you’ll likely get a different support representative every time, and they may not be knowledgeable about your issue.

As a result, complicated problems can be even more complicated to solve. Basic issues should be resolved quickly and easily at both places, though.

Divider 5

Which is Better for Pet Owners?

As you can probably tell from the information above, the sites are very similar in terms of their capabilities. You’re not likely to see a massive improvement by switching from one to the other.

Which one you should use depends largely on your buying habits. If you’re shopping exclusively for pet products, we think Chewy is likely the better choice due to their generous return policy, pharmacy department, and helpfully-designed site.

If, however, dog food is just one item on a long shopping list, you may find it easier just to do it all at Amazon. This is especially true if you’ve signed up for Prime and want to justify the expenditure.

Regardless, you should be able to find what you need at either place and get it in within a day or two. And no matter which site you buy from, one thing is for certain: your dog will be more interested in playing with the box everything came in than he is the $20 toy you bought him.