As loving dog owners, we all want to feed our dogs the best nutrition possible. But with so many foods competing in the market and overwhelming amounts of information to keep straight about our dogs’ nutrition, it can be a daunting task just picking which food to feed your furry companion.
Taste of the Wild dog foods offer premium nutrition for our canines made with quality ingredients to boost our dogs’ health. But even among this single brand, there are so many choices it can get confusing. So, we decided to try them all and see what our dogs think.
After testing so many of these foods, we decided to write up short reviews comparing each so that you can share in what we learned. Hopefully, it will save you the trouble and expense of testing them all yourself!
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
|Best Overall||Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Dry Dog Food||
|Best Value||Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Grain-Free Dry Dog Food||
|Best for Puppies||Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Puppy Dry Dog Food||
|Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Grain-Free Dog Dry Food||
|Taste of the Wild Wetlands Grain-Free Dry Dog Food||
The 10 Best Taste of the Wild Dog Foods – Reviews 2021
1. Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Dry Dog Food – Best Overall
Most dog owners would like to feed their canines the most natural foods possible to ensure they’re getting proper nutrition and eating the way their ancestors did. The Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Dry Dog Food is made with natural, whole-food ingredients that models the way your dog’s ancestors ate for centuries, so you can be certain that you’re feeding your pooch the highest quality nutrients.
Dogs need a lot of protein in their diets, which is why this food is packed with a minimum of 32% crude protein. But it gets even better; the protein comes from multiple different high-quality sources, providing your dog with a varied and balanced supply of essential amino acids. But all of those protein sources can be a bit difficult on some dogs’ digestive systems.
Of course, this food is packed with more than just protein. It’s also formulated with loads of other health-boosting nutrients to keep your canine in top shape. For instance, it’s got omega fatty acids to improve your dog’s coat and skin. Plus, prebiotics and antioxidants help maintain healthy digestive and immune systems.
2. Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
In the Western world, we overwhelmingly feed our dogs chicken. But dogs have taste buds like humans and have been known to become temperamental regarding their foods, refusing to eat foods that they’ve grown tired of. But the Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Grain-Free Dog Food uses real salmon as its main protein source, giving your dog a diverse new flavor scheme and amino acid profile. That means it doesn’t just taste good to your dog, it’s healthy for them as well. Unfortunately, it doesn’t contain as much protein as the High Prairie formula, which is why this one is our runner-up.
Like all Taste of the Wild foods, this one is crafted from real, whole-food ingredients to provide your pup with the healthy nutrition they need. And because it’s made with salmon rather than chicken, this food is a great option for many canines with food allergies.
Rather than using harder-to-digest grains, this formula is entirely grain-free. It’s still loaded with vital nutrients though, including omega fatty acids, chelated minerals, and prebiotics for digestive health.
3. Taste of the Wild High Prairie Puppy Dry Dog Food – Best for Puppies
Puppies are growing every day, so it’s essential to provide them with adequate nutrition to fuel their growing bodies and brains. That’s why the Taste of the Wild High Prairie Puppy Dry Dog Food is our top choice for puppies. It’s formulated with the vital nutrients that growing pups need to reach their maximum potential. For instance, this formula is fortified with DHA to help support healthy brain function.
But that’s not all. You’ll also find omega fatty acids for healthy skin and coat, plus chelated minerals to support the entire range of healthy functioning systems. You’ll even find high doses of antioxidants and prebiotics to keep the immune system and digestive system functioning at full capacity.
On the downside, some of our puppies got wicked gas from this food. It also made their stools soft. Not a dealbreaker, but it can definitely be hard on some puppies’ stomachs. Even still, our pups all seemed to love this food and kept coming back for more, so it gets the vote from us and our fur-pals.
4. Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
We eat different foods each day, but our dogs end up eating the same food with the same nutrients day in and day out, often for years on end. Not only can that get boring, but it doesn’t give your dog a very diverse nutrient profile. But the Sierra Mountain Grain-Free Dry Dog Food formula from Taste of the Wild is a great way to switch things up. Instead of chicken, this recipe uses lamb as its main source of protein, adding flavor and providing nutrients that your dog doesn’t usually get.
But lamb isn’t the only healthy, whole food in this formula. It’s packed with fruits and vegetables to provide necessary vitamins and minerals to your pooch. This formula even contains omega fatty acids for improved skin and coat and DHA to promote healthy brain function.
We did realize that it’s lacking in the protein department, though. While we like the high-quality lamb, 25% crude minimum protein just can’t compete with the other formulas from the same company. We also noticed something strange about this food; it made our dogs thirstier. They seemed to need several trips to the water bowl immediately after eating this food each time.
5. Taste of the Wild Wetlands Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
Taste of the Wild likes to get creative with their recipes, often using ingredients that you’ll rarely find in other brands’ blends. The Wetlands Grain-Free Dry Dog Food formula is no exception. They didn’t take the boring route with basic chicken. Instead, you’ll find duck listed as the main ingredient. You’ll also find smoked turkey, ocean fish meal, and roasted quail adding to the impressive 32% minimum crude protein.
We were quite impressed with the protein content and selection of this recipe. But our dogs weren’t quite as impressed as we were. At the end of the day, it doesn’t matter if we like the ingredients in a dog food if our pooches won’t eat it! Granted, many of our dogs had no problem with this food. But enough of them avoided it that we couldn’t ignore the issue.
While most Taste of the Wild formulas are fortified with health-boosting nutrients, we noticed that this blend is missing DHA, which is essential for brain health. It’s not the end of the world, but we prefer the formulas that include this important nutrient.
6. Taste of the Wild Southwest Canyon Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
We’re fans of feeding our dogs a diverse blend of healthy, whole-food ingredients; especially when it comes to protein sources. That’s one of the reasons we expected to like the Southwest Canyon Grain-Free Dog Food recipe. It lists beef as the main ingredient but also packs in a variety of other protein sources including lamb, wild boar, and ocean fish.
While we love the diverse protein sources on paper, it’s really our canines’ opinions who count the most. Unfortunately, they weren’t as thrilled about the protein sources as we were. In fact, many of our dogs flat-out refused to eat this food at all! Even when hungry, they’d barely pick at it, mostly just spilling the kibble onto the floor.
Of the dogs that ate this blend, several got gas and a few got diarrhea. This is just as unpleasant for us as for our pups, which is why this recipe didn’t earn a high position on our list. Still, we do like the ingredients and nutrient-profile of this formula, but none of that matters if the dogs vote no.
7. Taste of the Wild Pine Forest Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
We get the feeling that many dogs eating the Pine Forest Grain-Free Dog Food from Taste of the Wild are eating much better than their humans. One look at the ingredients list proves it; venison is listed as the main ingredient! But it also provides several other protein sources such as lamb and ocean fish.
But you’ll find a lot more than healthy protein sources in this blend. It’s made with loads of whole foods to provide your dog with precisely the nutrition it needs. But our dogs seemed completely oblivious to this since almost all of them rejected this food. They wouldn’t eat it, even if we added broth to it! They weren’t fooled. Despite the quality sources of protein and whole foods used in this blend, the dogs have decided it’s not up to their standard.
But some of our dogs did eat it, even if they didn’t seem too excited. Their stools all got very soft and runny afterward, indicating that perhaps the other pooches were right to stay away from this recipe.
8. Taste of the Wild Appalachian Valley Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
The Appalachian Valley Small Breed Grain-Free Dry Dog Food from Taste of the Wild follows the same formula as their other quality dry dog foods. It’s made with real, whole-food ingredients and packed with plenty of protein from diverse sources including venison, lamb, duck, and ocean fish. You’ll also find plenty of fruits and vegetables inside to provide your dog with much-needed vitamins, minerals, fatty acids, and other nutrients.
But despite all the positive benefits we expected, we were disappointed with this blend. It made quite a few of our dogs itchy. If it had happened to just one dog, we would have thought it was a fluke. But several of our dogs exhibited the same symptoms.
We also weren’t happy with the kibble size. This food is marketed for small breeds, but many of our small dogs had a hard time with these kibble pieces. They’re larger than the pieces in many other small breed formulas, making them a better choice for mid-sized breeds instead.
9. Taste of the Wild Wetlands Grain-Free Canned Dog Food
Often, if our dogs aren’t happy with a particular dry dog food, we’ll add some wet food to it to make it more appetizing. But the Taste of the Wild Wetlands Grain-Free Canned Dog Food doesn’t appeal to our pooches’ taste buds in the same way. We thought they’d be thrilled to eat this food, but some of them were utterly disinterested.
This might have something to do with the high amount of gravy used in this formula. It’s mostly gravy with a few chunks of meat. But the meat is made with some great protein sources like duck, chicken, quail, and fish. Plus, this recipe has a low carbohydrate content, providing your dog with the vital protein and fat it needs to be healthy.
Another drawback of this food is the high price. Compared to feeding your dog a dry food blend, this canned food isn’t cost-effective. Still, we could get past the price if our dogs really loved it. Since they don’t, we’ll stick to something more affordable that pleases the pooches too.
10. Taste of the Wild Ancient Prairie with Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food
Taking a different approach from the numerous grain-free formulas offered by Taste of the Wild, the Ancient Prairie with Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food opts for healthy grains and diverse protein sources. But the grains are harder for most dogs to digest, so dogs with stomach sensitivities should stay away from this recipe.
With a minimum of 32% crude protein, this blend packs in plenty to keep your pup functioning in peak condition. The protein also comes from diverse sources, such as buffalo, pork, chicken, bison, and even venison. But that’s probably part of why this food has such a strong, unpleasant odor.
The worst thing we noticed with this food though is the weight gain it caused in our dogs. After starting on this food, we noticed our dogs gaining several pounds each in a very short time. So, despite the diverse protein, we didn’t find enough to like about this food for us to recommend it.
If you want to take the fastest route, you could follow our recommendations and be certain that you’re feeding your dog quality nutrition. But what if you want to choose yourself? What traits should you be comparing and how do you tell which is best?
In this short buyer’s guide, we’re going to share the most important factors to keep in mind when picking a new food for your dog. If you prioritize these elements, you’ll be sure to pick the right food for your pooch every time.
Dogs need a lot of protein. Unlike humans, dogs’ bodies aren’t built to run on carbohydrates, so they need substantially more protein than us.
Look for a recipe that has a minimum protein content of 28% or higher. We’ve seen plenty of blends with 32% minimum protein, and this is one case where more is better. We generally opt for the blend with the highest protein levels for our dogs.
But total protein isn’t the whole picture. You also have to look at the protein sources that were used. Low-quality protein sources make low-quality food.
You want to find a food that uses real, whole-food ingredients. Look for a blend with a whole protein source listed as the main ingredient. Examples include roast duck, deboned beef, venison, buffalo, and more.
Growing dogs need a lot more than just protein though. That’s why we always look for blends that are packed with other essential nutrients to boost our dogs’ health.
Look for nutrients like DHA that boost brain health or omega fatty acids that keep your dogs’ skin and coat healthy. You’ll also want to see things like prebiotics for digestive health and antioxidants to keep their immune systems in top shape.
The Canine Test
Of course, none of that matters if your dog won’t eat the food, which is why the canine test is the most important factor when picking a new food for your dog. You won’t be eating it, they will!
Try feeding some of it to your dog mixed in with their current food. If they seem to reject it, you’ll need to pick a different formula. But if they seem receptive, then you’ll want to repeat the process the next day using more of the new food.
Regardless of how many healthy nutrients are packed into any dog food, they don’t do any good unless they make it into your dog’s stomach!
Throughout the process of trying out these dog foods and writing the corresponding reviews, we got to see how our canines react to many different formulas. Some were universally loved; others didn’t get the same warm reception. But at the end of the day, three Taste of the Wild dog foods impressed us enough to bear mentioning.
The Wild High Prairie Grain-Free formula was our favorite. It models how our dogs’ ancestors ate, using high-quality whole-food sources of protein, starting with real buffalo. It’s got 32% minimum crude protein, plus loads of other healthy nutrients to keep your dogs in tip-top shape.
The Pacific Stream Grain-Free food was our runner up. It’s a great option for dogs that have gotten tired of the same old food since it’s made with salmon instead of chicken. This also makes it a great choice for dogs with allergies. And of course, it’s made with healthy, whole-food ingredients.
And if you’re looking for puppy food, our top choice is the Wild High Prairie Puppy Formula. Not only is it made with multiple, high-quality protein sources, it’s also loaded with antioxidants, prebiotics, DHA, omega fatty acids, and chelated minerals, providing everything a growing puppy needs.
Featured Image Credit: manushot, Shutterstock
- A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
- The 10 Best Taste of the Wild Dog Foods – Reviews 2021
- 1. Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Dry Dog Food – Best Overall
- 2. Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
- 3. Taste of the Wild High Prairie Puppy Dry Dog Food – Best for Puppies
- 4. Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
- 5. Taste of the Wild Wetlands Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
- 6. Taste of the Wild Southwest Canyon Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
- 7. Taste of the Wild Pine Forest Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
- 8. Taste of the Wild Appalachian Valley Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
- 9. Taste of the Wild Wetlands Grain-Free Canned Dog Food
- 10. Taste of the Wild Ancient Prairie with Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food
- Buyer’s Guide