Best Elk Antler Chews for Dogs 2020 – Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated:

EcoKind Pet TreatsAntlers make fantastic chews for dogs because they’re natural, less likely to splinter than bones, and better for your dog’s teeth and gums. Thanks to the nutritious marrow inside, they’re a great source of vitamins and minerals for your dog. Elk antlers make especially great chews because they’re bigger and long-lasting. 

There are many different brands that sell elk antlers, so it’s hard to know what to choose. We’ve created a list of in-depth reviews to help you find the best ones for your pup. We’ve also included a buying guide so you know what to look for in the best elk antler chews.


A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

ModelPriceAntler QuantityEditor Rating
Devil Dog
Devil Dog(Best Overall)

Check Price
1 pc4.90/5
Barkworthies
Barkworthies(Best Value)

Check Price
1 pc4.75/5
Deluxe Naturals
Deluxe Naturals(Premium Choice)

Check Price
6 to 8 pcs4.55/5
Pet Parents
Pet Parents

Check Price
1 pc4.30/5
Elkhorn
Elkhorn

Check Price
1 pc3.90/5

The 10 Best Elk Antler Chews for Dogs — Reviews 2020

1. Devil Dog Premium Elk Antlers — Best Overall

Devil Dog

The Devil Dog Premium Elk Antlers are our best overall choice because they’re from naturally shed antlers that are wild sourced. This makes them an excellent eco-friendly choice. They have no odor and no mess. The antlers are available in many different sizes, so you can pick the best one for your pup. The marrow is nutrient-dense, which gives your dog a healthy treat to chew. They also don’t splinter, so you don’t have to worry about your dog swallowing a dangerous piece. The antlers tend to last for months. They can also help remove tartar from your dog’s teeth. 

This is a pricey antler, and there’s only one in the package. If you have multiple dogs, it can get expensive buying each of them an antler. 

Pros
  • Wild-sourced, naturally-shed antlers
  • Available in many different sizes 
  • No odor, no mess
  • Nutrient dense, no splintering
  • Long-lasting
  • Helps remove tartar from teeth
Cons
  • Expensive; only one antler in package

2. Barkworthies Whole Elk Antlers — Best Value

Barkworthies

The Barkworthies Whole Elk Antlers are the best elk antler chews for dogs for the money because the antlers are hand-selected, cut, and then sanded down to give your dog a safely-sized chew. They are available as whole or split antlers, so you can choose the best one for your dog’s chewing style. The antlers are naturally long-lasting. They’re also low mess and odor free. 

The antlers are small and thin, even in the bigger sizes. 

Pros
  • Naturally shed by roaming elk
  • Antlers are hand-selected and cut to size
  • Available in whole and split 
  • Naturally long-lasting
  • Low-mess and odor-free chew
Cons
  • Small and thin

3. Deluxe Naturals Naturally Shed Elk Antlers — Premium Choice

Deluxe Naturals

The Deluxe Naturals Naturally Shed Elk Antlers is our premium choice because each 1-pound package contains multiple antlers. The antlers are naturally shed and then cut to size. Each antler is rich in calcium, phosphorus, and protein to help support your dog’s healthy bones and teeth. The chews are odor free and long-lasting. They’re also sanitized using the ozone method. 

The antlers are expensive due to the 1-pound package. There also seem to be quality-control issues. Sometimes, the antlers are split and other times, they’re whole. They’re not always long-lasting. 

Pros
  • Multiple antlers in one package
  • Naturally shed and cut to size 
  • Elk antlers are rich in calcium, phosphorus, and protein
  • Odor-free, long-lasting chews
  • Sanitized with ozone method 
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Quality-control issues 

4. Pet Parents Gnawtlers Elk Antlers

Pet Parents

The Pet Parents Gnawtlers Elk Antlers are specially selected for their weight, density, color, and shape, so you can be sure that you’re getting a good-quality antler for your pup. The antlers are picked up when they’re freshly shed and then vacuum packed to keep them fresh. The antlers aren’t processed and contain no dyes, so you don’t have to worry about your dog getting exposed to any chemicals or toxins. 

These antlers don’t last as long for aggressive chewers. They can also splinter into shards that can be harmful to your dog’s mouth. 

Pros
  • Specially selected for weight, density, color, and shape
  • Not processed; no dyes
  • Freshly-shed
  • Vacuum-sealed packaging
Cons
  • Not for aggressive chewers
  • Can result in splintered shards

5. Elkhorn Premium Chews Elk Antler

Elkhorn

The Elkhorn Premium Chews Elk Antler is a long-lasting whole antler chew. Each antler is at least 6 inches long. The antlers are hand cut and then smoothed to remove any sharp edges, which makes it safer for your dog to chew. The antlers are naturally shed and hand collected from wild elk. 

These aren’t the best antlers for power chewers because they aren’t wide enough to last that long. Since they’re whole antlers instead of split, some dogs have trouble getting to the marrow.

Pros
  • Long-lasting whole (non-split) antler chew
  • Large size 
  • Each piece is hand-cut and then smoothed to remove any sharp edges
  • Hand-collected from wild elk
Cons
  • Not good for power chewers
  • Whole antlers aren’t good for all dogs 

6. The Antler Box Premium Elk Antler

The Antler Box

The Antler Box Premium Elk Antler contains 1 pound of antler chews, which is ideal if you have more than one dog. The antlers are naturally shed from wild, Rocky Mountain elk. The box that the antlers come in is plastic-free, biodegradable, and eco-friendly. It includes whole and split antlers, which is great for households that have dogs with different chewing styles. 

Because it’s a 1-pound box, these antlers are expensive. Due to packaging by weight, they may not be four antlers in a box. It may be fewer than the manufacturer has pictured. 

Pros
  • 1-pound box of elk antler chews
  • Naturally-shed antler chews from Rocky Mountain elk
  • Plastic-free, biodegradable, eco-friendly packaging
  • Whole and split-mixed box
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Due to packaging by weight, there may not be four antlers as pictured

7. Big Dog Antler Chews

Big Dog Antler Chews

The Big Dog Antler Chews are custom-cut, trimmed, and sanded so all the sharp edges are smooth. This makes them safer for your dog to chew. The antlers contain no chemicals or added preservatives because they’re from wild elk. They should be cleaned only with water. 

The antlers can splinter into sharp shards, so be sure to supervise your dog while chewing. It’s a two-pack of antlers, which makes it more expensive. The antlers aren’t long-lasting for aggressive chewers. 

Pros
  • Custom cut, trimmed to size, and sanded
  • No chemicals or added preservatives
  • Cleaned only with water
  • All sharp edges have been sanded smooth
Cons
  • Can result in splintered shards
  • Expensive
  • Not long-lasting

8. WhiteTail Naturals Premium Split Elk Antlers

WhiteTail Naturals

The WhiteTail Naturals Premium Split Elk Antlers come in a package that contains two large split-antler chews, which is great if you have more than one dog. Each chew is at least 6 inches long. The chews are hand-selected from naturally-shed elk antlers. These chews are mess free and odorless. 

The chews can sometimes result in splintered shards, so you should supervise your dog while it’s chewing. Split antlers aren’t great for aggressive chewers because they don’t last as long. Some packages have a strong odor. 

Pros
  • Split-antler for medium and large dogs
  • Package contains two large split-antler chews 
  • Hand-selected from naturally-shed antlers 
  • Mess free and odorless
Cons
  • Can result in splintered shards
  • Not for power chewers
  • Some packages have a strong odor

9. Chipper Critters Whole Elk Antler Dog Chew

Chipper Critters

The Chipper Critters Whole Elk Antler Dog Chew is available in whole and split elk antlers, which lets you choose the best one for your dog’s chewing style. There are multiple choices for chew sizes that depend on your dog’s weight. Depending on which size you choose, some of the antlers come in a two-pack. 

These chews can result in splintered shards, so be sure to watch your dog while chewing. These aren’t the best choice for aggressive chewers. They also seem rather dried out, which means they aren’t that fresh. 

Pros
  • Elk antlers available in whole and split 
  • Sized appropriately by dog weight
  • Some antlers available in a two-pack
Cons
  • Can result in splintered shards
  • Not for power chewers
  • Too dried out
  • Not packaged at peak freshness 

10. EcoKind Pet Treats Natural Elk Antler

EcoKind Pet Treats

The EcoKind Pet Treats Elk Antler is sourced from naturally shed antlers from Rocky Mountain elk. Each bag contains multiple antler chews, so it’s ideal for households with many dogs. 

Because each bag contains multiple chews, they are expensive. The antlers are quite large, which can be hard for some dogs to chew. They can also result in splintered shards, so it’s best to supervise your dog while chewing. Quality control isn’t consistent with these chews, as some are too short and some are much too big. 

Pros
  • Sourced from naturally shed antlers from Rocky Mountain elk
  • Multiple antlers in one bag 
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Too large
  • Can result in splintered shards
  • Some are too short 
  • Quality-control issues 

Buyer’s Guide

Elk antlers make great chews for dogs because they’re naturally shed, so they are a renewable resource. Companies who hand-select the antlers and sell them all have different methods of producing the finished antler chew. To help you understand what makes a great elk antler chew, we’ve created a buyer’s guide. 

 

Split Elk Antlers

Split elk antlers are where the antlers have been split open to reveal the nutritious marrow inside. These are ideal for older dogs, puppies, or dogs who aren’t used to chewing. They are not a good option for aggressive chewers, because they don’t last long. 

Whole Elk Antlers

Whole elk antlers are left whole rather than split open to reveal the marrow inside. This makes it more of a challenge for your dog to get through the tough antler on the outside. Whole elk antlers are ideal for more aggressive chewers because whole antlers last longer. 

Cut to Size

Although the elk antlers are naturally shed on the forest floor, they need to be cut down to a manageable size. Many companies offer a variety of sizes that are suitable for different dog weights and breeds. You should also take into account your dog’s chewing style when you choose an elk antler chew. More aggressive chewers can handle a bigger antler chew, and tentative or occasional chewers benefit from smaller ones. 

Sanded Down

To make the elk antler safe for your dog to chew, it needs to be sanded down first. This eliminates sharp points or shards that can cut your dog’s mouth. 

dog chewing antlers
Image Credit: the happiest face, Pexels

Sanitized

Some antler chews have been sanitized by natural methods before packaging. This is ideal for preventing any kind of bacteria or disease from spreading. 

 Freshness

Elk antlers that have been harvested shortly after being shedding, sanitized, and vacuum-packed will have the freshest marrow. If there is an odor to the antler or if it seems dry, then these are signs that the antlers were either old during harvesting or have been packaged for too long. 

Conclusion

Our best overall choice is the Devil Dog Premium Elk Antlers because they’re taken from naturally-shed antlers from wild elk. The antlers have no odor and no mess, and they’re available in many different sizes. This lets you pick the best one for your dog’s size and chewing style. 

Our best value choice is the Barkworthies Whole Elk Antlers because they are hand-selected from naturally shed antlers. The antlers are sanded and cut to size so they’re easy for your dog to chew. They’re also available in whole or split antler versions. 

We hope that our list of reviews and buyer’s guide have helped you find the best elk antler chews for your dog.


Featured Image Credit: EcoKind Pet Treats, Amazon