Best Dog Litter Box 2020 – Guide, Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated:

A Dog Litter BoxAs dog owners, we want to provide the best for our pets and manage their needs effectively. Sometimes, we have to be away from them while we are at work, or perhaps you have a senior dog who has a difficult time walking outdoors. Whatever your reason, a dog litter box canp provide benefits to you and your pooch.

They are an inexpensive option, at least compared to replacing carpets or other objects that could become stained. Our review guide focuses on six of the best dog litter boxes tod consider. We will go over the pros/cons of each, and we’ve also included a buyer’s guide with useful tips for buying a litter box.

A Comparison Table (updated in 2020):

ModelPriceSizes AvailableEditor Rating
DoggieLawn
Real Grass
small DoggieLawn Real Grass Dog Litter Box(Best Overall)

Check Price
2 Sizes4.85/5
Nature's Miracle P-82035
small Natures Miracle P-82035(Best Value)

Check Price
1 Size4.70/5
PuppyGoHere 2420R
small PuppyGoHere 2420R(Premium Choice)

Check Price
3 Sizes4.65/5
SO PHRESH
small SO PHRESH Dog Litter Box

Check Price
2 Sizes4.40/5
Petmate 22211
small Petmate 22211

Check Price
1 Size4.20/5

The 6 Best Dog Litter Boxes:

1. DoggieLawn Real Grass Dog Litter Box — Best Overall

DoggieLawn Real Grass Dog Litter Box

This DoggieLawn is a great size for small to medium-sized dogs, as it is 24×16 inches of hydroponic grass. Dogs usually prefer real grass to fake grass and so will be happy to do their business in this litter box. It is ideal for potty-training and/or apartments, since it absorbs liquids and odors like regular grass, and the cardboard bottom is lined to prevent leaking.

We like the fact that there is no cleaning involved, except of course, to scoop up solid waste. Otherwise, you can dispose of the grass in your compost or trash. Since it is live grass, a small amount of watering is required, but the grass should live for a couple of weeks (or longer) depending on frequency of use.

A nice feature offered by the company is free consults during business hours regarding any training issues or concerns. You can also subscribe to receive scheduled shipments of replacement grass. DoggieLawn does offer different box sizes to accommodate larger dogs. On the downside, this becomes a pricier option if you have to replace the grass more than every two weeks.

Pros
  • Real grass
  • Absorbs liquids and odors
  • Lined base
  • Easy to clean and dispose of
  • Grass replacements
  • Free training consultations
  • Different sizes available
Cons
  • Pricey
  • Grass needs watered

2. Nature’s Miracle High-Sided Litter Box — Best Value

Natures Miracle P-82035

This is the best dog litter box for your money. It is 23×18.5×11 inches, which should work well for smaller pets. It has antimicrobial product protection with a non-stick surface that makes it easy to clean. Plus, the high sides help prevent scattering of paper pellets.

We like that Nature’s Miracle offers a liner that will fit this box for even easier cleanup when the pellets need to be replaced. On the downside, it only comes in the color black, which tends to show dirt and residue. This litter box is an affordable price, but the DoggieLawn is a product that some dogs may prefer to use over a box filled with pellets, which is why Nature’s Miracle isn’t in the number-one spot.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Antimicrobial
  • Non-stick surface
  • High-sides
  • Liner available
Cons
  • Only in black

3. PuppyGoHere Dog Litter Box — Premium Choice

PuppyGoHere 2420R

Here is a litter box that is a great option for small dogs, cats, and rabbits. The size is 24x20x5 inches and comes in a multitude of colors. We like that it has a training guide to assist with training your puppy.

The grey box option is made from recycled plastic, which may result in different shades of grey. There are plenty of size options to choose from. The low-entry side is easy for puppies to get into, and since the whole box has a low center of gravity, it is nearly impossible to tip over. It is easy to clean, and you can place puppy pads or pellets inside the box.

On the negative side, it does slide around easily on hard floors, but placing a no-slip mat underneath can remedy that problem. The PuppyGoHere did not make the top two spots because it is pricier overall.

Pros
  • Good for small dogs
  • Training guide included
  • Recycled plastic
  • Won’t tip over easily
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Slides easily
  • Pricey

Why is your dog eating grass? Click here to find out!


4. SO PHRESH Dog Litter Box

SO PHRESH Dog Litter Box

The SO PHRESH litter box is another option for indoor training for your puppy. It is strong and sturdy, measuring 19.5×23.5×5 inches. We like that it is made in the U.S.A. and has a low-entry side that is easy for puppies to enter and exit.

On the downside, the bottom is bowed, so when the dog steps into the box, it pops up and down with movement. Also, it doesn’t come in a larger size if you need one for a larger dog. It is easy to clean, though, and doesn’t slide easily on hard floors.

Pros
  • Strong
  • Made in the U.S.A.
  • Low-entry side
  • Easy to clean
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Bottom bows
  • No larger size available

Check out the top water bottles for your dog’s crate here!


5. Petmate 22211 Litter Pan

Petmate 22211

The Petmate is a large litter pan with deep sides and measures 25.56×18.3×10.02. We like how deep it is to contain messes but found that it is difficult for smaller dogs to get in and out of, since there is no low-entry side available.

It is made in the U.S.A. from durable, eco-friendly plastic. We found that it is strong and easy to clean. Due to the size and weight, it does not slip around on hard floors, making it easier for dogs to get in and out.

This is a good option to use in an apartment, as it will accommodate larger dogs easily.

Pros
  • Large size
  • Deep sides
  • Made in the U.S.A.
  • Easy to clean
  • No slipping
  • Affordable
Cons
  • No low-entry side

See: The top dog food for less poop!


6. PS Korea Indoor Dog Litter Box

PS Korea Indoor Dog Litter Box

The PS Korea offers a unique design with a perforated grate at the bottom of the crate that allows the urine to flow down to pads underneath. We like how the grate snaps into place so it doesn’t come out with movement. With the high-sided walls, it contains the dog within the area so they won’t accidentally make a mess on the floor.

It is ideal for small to medium-sized dogs since it is 22.5×17.77×6.1 inches. This box stays in place and does not tip over, and it is not difficult for a puppy to get in and out of. On the downside, it is not as affordable as others on this list, and the grate is difficult to clean.

Pros
  • Perforated grate
  • Three high-side walls
  • No slipping
  • Low center of gravity
  • Easy to get in and out
Cons
  • Pricey
  • Grate difficult to clean

See: The top grooming tables for dogs


Buyer’s Guide

When looking to buy the perfect dog litter box, there are a few considerations to keep in mind and questions to ask yourself. In this section, we will discuss these considerations, as well as provide useful tips that will make the process of buying a dog litter box easier.

Reasons to Purchase a Dog Litter Box

  • You live in an apartment with no access to grass nearby.
  • It is difficult for you to take your dog outside due to mobility issues.
  • You want to start house-training your puppy.
  • You want to use it during times of inclement weather.
  • You have a dog who has trouble controlling their bodily functions.
  • You have a dog who’s recovering from an illness or injury.
  • You are away from home for most of the day.

Types of Dog Litter Boxes

Conventional Litter box

These are recognizable litter boxes, as well as those that are simple in design and use. Certain ones can be used for cats and other animals as well, but what makes this useful for a dog is the three high sidewalls and a side that is low entry.

They are not filled with traditional litter but instead, paper pellets made out of recycled newspaper. The conventional litter box is usually more affordable and easy to clean and comes in a variety of sizes. On the downside, you will have to keep change the pellets out so they do not become odorous from urine.

Plastic Crates

These have a floating grate along the bottom, where urine drains through onto an absorbent pad and any solid waste will sit on the top (which will have to be removed and discarded). If they have sides, they are usually not that high.

A nice thing about these is that they keep your dog’s paws dry and hold the absorbent pad in place. A disadvantage is having to clean up the feces in a timely manner so it doesn’t become odorous.

Dog Litter Box

Do you have a pit bull? Click here to check out the best crates for pit bulls

Real Grass

Dogs love to do their business on real grass, so these litter boxes provide a patch of live grass that is held in place by a low-walled cardboard box. The box will most likely be lined to prevent liquids from saturating the cardboard, allowing it to last longer. Certain companies will sell pieces of sod separately so you don’t have to buy a whole new system each time.

You do have to water the grass to keep it lush, and it will last approximately one to two weeks, depending on how often your dog uses it. You will have to clean the grass of the solid waste, but the urine will be absorbed by the dirt. These systems tend to be on the pricier end.

Considerations

Cost: We always want to provide the best for our pets, but most of us are on a budget and need to take into account the expense of a dog litter box, as well as the continued cost of replacing grass, pellets, or absorbent pads.

Dog size: The size of your dog will determine the size of the box you need to purchase. Dogs like to circle before they go to the bathroom so they will need adequate space to move around. Most systems are ideal for small to medium-sized dogs.

Materials: You will want a system that is durable and holds up to frequent use. If you have a puppy who likes to chew, keep the type of material in mind.

Design: If you have a puppy or a smaller breed, a high-sided box may be difficult for them to get in and out of. Some designs are heavier than others so they won’t slide around or if they have a lower center of gravity, they won’t tip over as easily.

Ease of use: When you are dealing with dog waste, it’s best for everyone involved if the system is easy to use and to clean. Some surfaces are easier to wipe down than others, and with certain systems, there are options to purchase liners separately.

Tips

  • A dog litter box should be functional, hygienic, and comfortable for your dog to use.
  • Consider features such as drainage holes and waste trays.
  • Some dogs may not like to use a litter box, especially if they were not introduced at a young age.
  • If your dog prefers to urinate by lifting a leg, they may miss the litter box entirely.
  • Training guides are beneficial when introducing a box to your dog.
  • Unfortunately, some dogs will eat another dog’s poop, so if you have more than one pet, you will want to keep the system free of feces at all times.

Did you know the border collie, the havanese, and the miniature schnauzer are some of the easiest dogs to train? We offer complete guides for these breeds – check them out below:

Conclusion

Even though litter boxes are typically marketed for cats, there’s no reason to dismiss the idea of getting one for your dog. Litter boxes do not replace taking your dog outside, but they can be another option for when you are training your puppy or if you are gone during the day.

Our reviews list focuses on six of the best dog litter boxes. Our top choice is the DoggieLawn, offering live grass that any dog would love to use. The best value pick is the Natures Miracle, which is a traditional system that is affordable and easy to use. Our premium choice is the PuppyGoHere litter box with its low-entry side and low center of gravity — a good option if the price isn’t a concern.

Our wish is to equip you with the knowledge to confidently purchase a dog litter box that will be appreciated by you and your pet. We hope our review list and buyer’s guide decreases some of the frustration that comes with choosing a litter box that works well, is durable, and is easy to use.


Featured Image Credit By: DoggieLawn Real Grass Dog Potty, amazon