Best Dog Collar for Pulling 2020 – Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated:

Best Collar for PullingYour dog pulling on the leash is more than just inconvenient for you. It can be scary for the people you pass, and potentially dangerous for your pooch, too. If your dog pulls hard enough to yank the leash from your grip, what’s to stop them from running into traffic or lunging at another dog? No one wants a dog that’s unruly on the leash, but fixing it can be a difficult problem. If you’ve ever tried a dog collar that’s intended to stop pulling, your experience may have been hit or miss. These collars are not created equally, so we’ve tried as many as possible to see which ones are worth investing in. The following ten reviews will share all that we learned while training our dogs with these collars, so hopefully, it will help make the decision easier for you.


A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

ModelPriceSizes AvailableEditor Rating
Mighty Paw
small Mighty Paw(Best Overall)

Check Price
3 Sizes4.90/5
StarMark TCLC
small StarMark TCLC(Best Value)

Check Price
2 Sizes4.75/5
Sporn 10042
small Sporn 10042(Premium Choice)

Check Price
4 Sizes4.70/5
Country Brook
small Country Brook Petz NM1-RED-M

Check Price
4 Sizes4.50/5
Halti
small Halti COA12200BLK

Check Price
6 Sizes4.45/5

The 10 Best Dog Collars for Pulling – Reviews

1. Mighty Paw Martingale Collar – Best Overall

Mighty Paw

Durable and effective, the Mighty Paw Martingale collar was a pleasure to use. As dog owners, we never want to hurt our four-legged companions, so this collar only tightens enough to send a training cue your dog will understand. It won’t choke them or cause any pain; it just gets the message across with pressure. Moreover, when you pull the leash and the chain tightens, the sound is quite audible since it’s right next to the dog’s ear. The sound acts as a second signal to your dog, helping make this collar even more effective.

We have dogs of all different sizes, and with the largest ones, we worry about durability. Luckily, the Mighty Paw collar is very heavy-duty and even after many weeks of daily walks on our largest canines it didn’t show any signs of wear. In the dark, the reflective stitching makes sure your dog is always visible, an added bonus that we appreciate. The only downside we noticed is that this collar did leave a gray mark on light-colored fur.

Pros
  • Tightens just enough to send a training cue
  • Heavy-duty build quality
  • Reflective stitching helps you see your dog in the dark
  • Sound from train aids in training
Cons
  • Stains light-colored fur

2. StarMark TCLC Training Collar – Best Value

StarMark TCLC

If metal pronged collars seem too harsh and aggressive to put around your furry loved one, then you may consider the StarMark TCLC Training Collar instead. Rather than using metal spikes, this collar employs soft plastic points that will get your dog’s attention and make your message clear without causing them any pain. It features a Martingale design that tightens up just enough to apply pressure without choking your dog, as long as it’s sized properly. The nylon Martingale strap is thin and doesn’t inspire confidence with larger dogs. Luckily, they won’t be pulling on it hard so it should last. In our experience, it didn’t break or fray, but it’s thinner than we’re comfortable with. This collar also wasn’t as effective on our dogs with thick neck pads like Pit Bulls and Bulldogs.

For proper fitting, each link can be removed and more can be added to adjust this collar to whatever size you need. That said, it’s very difficult to resize and getting each link on and off was a pain! One broke in the process, so make sure you’re careful when you attempt it. Altogether, we think it’s the best dog collar for pulling for the money.

Pros
  • Can add or remove links to adjust the size
  • Doesn’t choke when sized properly
  • Doesn’t hurt but gets their attention
  • The nylon strap is thin and doesn’t inspire confidence
Cons
  • Less effective on dogs with thick neck pads
  • Very difficult to resize

3. Sporn Vest Collar Halter – Premium Choice

Sporn 10042

Protected by a lifetime guarantee, the Sporn Step-in Vest Collar Halter is our premium choice recommendation. Many pet owners are justifiably concerned with choking their dog or impaling their neck with hard metal spikes, as are we! The Sporn collar halter has a step-in design that allows the pressure to be exerted around their front legs instead of the neck. We were a bit apprehensive about its effectiveness at first, but after using it our doubts were quashed.

There were two things we didn’t love about this collar. First, if you don’t get it properly fit then your dog may wriggle out. The tightening clip itself isn’t the most durable though and is the weak point of the whole harness. This didn’t bother us too much since the lifetime guarantee will replace it if it breaks. This collar is available in sizes to fit dogs from 5 pounds up to 130 pounds. When we pulled the leash, it would immediately cause the dog to stop and wait. Overall, it was one of the most effective ones we tried which is why it’s our premium choice.

Pros
  • Doesn’t choke your dog
  • Pulls on front legs to stop your dog
  • Sizes for dogs from 5lbs to 130lbs
  • Lifetime guarantee
Cons
  • If not set up properly, your dog may escape
  • Tightening clip isn’t very durable

4. Country Brook Martingale Nylon Dog Collar

Country Brook Petz NM1-RED-M

Affordable, durable, and stylish, the Country Brook Petz Martingale color is made from nylon with no chain so it’s more comfortable for your dog. Since it is a Martingale design, it will still tighten up with the pull of the leash to signal to your canine companion that they need to stop pulling. The pressure is gentle yet firm and it won’t choke your pup.

For those who like to stand out and be unique, this collar is available in 20 different colors for you to choose from. However, be careful using it on dogs with light fur as the color will wear off onto their coat leaving a bright-colored ring! You may be able to avoid this by washing it first, but it’s a noticeable problem and the staining it left did not want to wash out of our dog’s fur. There’s no buckle so it’s a bit more difficult to put on, but that also means there’s less chance of it breaking.

Pros
  • 20 color options
  • All nylon for your dog’s comfort – no metal
  • Applies pressure to neck when pulled
Cons
  • No buckle so It’s more difficult to put on
  • Color can rub off on lighter fur

5. Halti COA12200BLK Head Collar

Halti COA12200BLK

The Halti Head Collar helps gently steer your dog when you pull on the leash by gently applying pressure to their snout. Because of the design, it doesn’t choke your dog or even tighten around their neck, instead, using a head collar that wraps around the head and snout to relay the message. You don’t have to pull hard to make your point, either. After prolonged use, it will need repeated tightening. If you forget, you may find your dog wriggling his way out of the head harness.

For your dog’s comfort, this harness is constructed from nylon. It’s supposed to be very durable, but that wasn’t our experience. Our collar started fraying where the nylon rubs against the metal ring after just a few walks. Eventually, it had weakened so much that one of our dogs lunged after a stray bunny and snapped the nylon. We like the concept of this collar, but wish it provided better longevity.

Pros
  • Doesn’t choke your dog
  • Requires very little pulling pressure
Cons
  • Nylon wears out from abrasion
  • Loosens up and needs tightening

6. Coastal Walk’n Train Head Halter Collar

Coastal Walkn Train

Unlike collars that stop pulling by choking your dog, the Coastal Walk’n Train steers your dog by their snout. It features an extra clip in case they wriggle out of the head halter. If you’re worried about appearances, this halter looks a bit like a muzzle, which may be a turnoff for some people. Since it is designed to go around the snout, it doesn’t work well with dogs that have very short snouts.

Some of our dogs didn’t seem phased by this halter and just kept pulling. Our other dogs responded well, but they didn’t enjoy having the harness wrapped around their mouths. It also tended to migrate back and cover their eyes, so we had to make continuous adjustments while walking. It is a very affordable solution, but the hit-or-miss performance with our pups means it won’t earn one of our top recommendations.

Pros
  • Very affordable
  • Doesn’t choke your dog
  • Extra clip to secure to dog’s collar
Cons
  • Looks like a muzzle
  • Didn’t work with all of our dogs
  • Doesn’t fit small snouts
  • Straps migrate back onto eyes

7. PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar

PetSafe GL-Q-HC-L-BLK

With eight colors to choose from, the PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar is an affordable and stylish way to train your dog to stop pulling on the leash. We like the concept, but the execution isn’t quite there. There’s a plastic clasp that holds the collar on, but it’s very weak and broke on our second walk. To make matters worse, the nylon used to craft this collar is too thin and can break on its own if the clasp manages to hold up. Since it goes around your dog’s snout, they’ll likely try to chew through it. To that end, PetSafe offers a 1-year chew damage replacement, but that’s not enough to earn this collar a higher spot on our list.

Pros
  • 8 color options
  • 1-year chew damage replacement
Cons
  • The plastic clasp is a weak point
  • Too easy to wriggle out of
  • Weak nylon breaks easily

8. Dazzber Dog Collar

Dazzber

Constructed of durable and soft nylon for your pet’s ultimate comfort, the Dazzber dog collar is a Martingale design that discourages pulling by tightening around your dog’s neck. Since there’s no metal, it doesn’t make any audible sound to reinforce the point, but it also is less likely to actually hurt your dog. There’s no buckle, so it’s a bit difficult to get on and off. Once it’s on, you can tighten the adjustment straps, but they loosened up quickly and needed to be retightened after just a short bit. Despite the drawbacks, the Dazzber collar is more expensive than its closest competitors. While it does work, we think you can get the same performance at a cheaper price.

Pros
  • Durable and won’t break
Cons
  • More expensive than similar competitors
  • No buckle so it’s harder to put on
  • Tends to loosen up during a walk

9. Dog-Thing Dog Training Prong Collar

Dog-Thing

Constructed of interlocking steel links and prongs, the Dog-Thing training prong collar is a formidable choke chain that will likely intimidate some people. Many people are justifiably wary of putting metal spikes into their dog’s neck. It’s overkill unless you have a beast of an unruly dog. That said, it is effective at stopping pulling and lunging. It’s also very easy to hurt your dog, especially if you’re not well versed in its proper use. With this model, we had one of the links pop off mid-walk, releasing the dog to run free. This is a danger to your pup and anyone else around. We’d recommend the StarMark training collar in position two instead, since it’s gentler on your dog and still stops them from pulling.

Pros
  • Effective at stopping lunging and pulling
Cons
  • Easy to hurt your dog
  • Requires proper knowledge of its use
  • Links pop off releasing the dog

10. Hamilton C3200 Training Collar

Hamilton C3200

Dirt cheap and definitely effective, the Hamilton training collar is also uncomfortable and potentially dangerous. It’s hard to get on and off your dog since you have to unhook a link. Once on, the spikes dig into your dog’s neck. When you pull the leash, they dig harder and your dog will stop moving. We’d only suggest this for large and rambunctious dogs that are very difficult to control, except that it’s not durable enough! Ours actually snapped during testing, which surprised us since it’s made of metal. In the end, we just don’t think it’s one of the better options since more reliable collars are available in the same price range.

Pros
  • Dirt cheap
Cons
  • Very difficult to put on and take off
  • Weak – snapped with our bigger dog
  • Can easily hurt your dog if done improperly

Conclusion

With so many options available, it’s difficult to know which collar will stop your dog from pulling on the leash without hurting them. We’ve tried as many as we could get a hold of and compiled our findings into the ten reviews you’ve just read. Our favorite was the Mighty Paw Martingale collar since it refrained our dogs from pulling and didn’t cause them any discomfort. It’s heavy-duty enough for large dogs and tightens just enough to send a training cue without choking them.

For the best value, we think it’s hard to beat the StarMark TCLC training collar. The soft spikes will get the message through to your dog without hurting them and links can be removed or added to achieve the perfect fit for any pooch. For a premium offering, the Sporn Step-in Vest Collar Halteris an excellent choice that pulls on your dog’s front legs instead of choking them. It was very effective in our testing and even includes a lifetime guarantee. All three of these will make great choices for training your doggo to stop pulling, and we feel confident recommending them.


Featured Image Credit By: Dazzber Dog Collar, amazon