Best Dog Bones for Aggressive Chewers 2020 – Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated:

A dog chew toy bone

If you own a dog who’s an aggressive chewer, you know the frustration of discovering everything from your favorite pair of running shoes to an important bill chewed up like yesterday’s dinner. The best solution is to offer your dog a chew toy or bone that’s made to last and interesting enough to hold their attention.

Step into any pet store or conduct a quick search online, and you’ll find plenty of dog bones claiming to be up to the task of appeasing your aggressive chewer. You may not be sure which dog bone is worth trying, especially when choosing incorrectly may mean coming home to discover your couch pillows in shreds.

Fortunately, we’ve done the investigating for you and determined the top 10 best dog bones for aggressive chewers. Starting with our top pick, we’ve included helpful reviews followed by quick-reference pros and cons lists to help you find the right dog bone for your dog.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Natural Farm Natural Farm
  • Ideal consistency for aggressive chewers
  • Premium ingredients
  • Low odor
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Hartz 3270005415 Hartz 3270005415
  • Toy and treat in one
  • Dental health benefits
  • Bacon flavor that dogs prefer
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Pawstruck Pawstruck
  • Naturally removes plaque and tartar
  • High-quality
  • Natural ingredients
  • Nylabone NBC107P Nylabone NBC107P
  • Long-lasting
  • Durable
  • Improved dental health
  • Petstages 219 Petstages 219
  • Resembles an actual stick
  • Taste and texture most dogs enjoy
  • Ideal for retrieval training and play
  • The 10 Best Dog Bones for Aggressive Chewers

    1. Natural Farm Dog Chew Bones – Best Overall

    Natural Farm

    We recommend Natural Farm Dog as one of the best dog chew bones on the market. These premium dog bones are sourced from beef ribs of farm-raised, grass-fed cattle and are free of hormones, grains, and additives. They provide aggressive chewers with plenty of toughness, as well as heartiness to hold their interest for a significant amount of time.

    These high-quality, all-natural treats are slow-roasted for a tasty and enticing flavor that nearly all dogs prefer, and you most likely will enjoy their low level of odor. In addition to appeasing your aggressive chewer, these dog chew bones have added dental health benefits by cleaning teeth and gums and removing plaque and tartar.

    Natural Farm Dog chew bones are suitable for nearly all size dogs. We found only a rare instance of these bones splintering.

    Pros
    • Ideal consistency for aggressive chewers
    • Premium ingredients
    • Free of hormones, grains, and additives
    • Most dogs like the flavor
    • Low odor
    • Dental health benefits
    • Suitable for nearly all size dogs
    Cons
    • Rare instance of splintering

    2. Hartz Chew’n Clean Dog Bone Toy – Best Value

    Hartz

    Our choice for the best dog bones for aggressive chewers for the money goes to Hartz Chew ’n Clean dog chew toy. For a lower price, you can offer your dog a combination of a treat and a chew toy in one. Rather gobbling up the treat in a few seconds, your dog will work their jaws and keep occupied over a longer period of time.

    The durable nylon shell contains an inviting bacon flavor that most dogs prefer. Plus, this shell contains nubs to massage your dog’s gums while gently removing plaque and tartar. The treat portion contains DentaShield, which further reduces plaque and tartar buildup.

    However, the entire bone may become consumed, resulting in your dog potentially ingesting the nylon shell. Also, after your aggressive chewer is done with it, sharp remnants may be left behind that can be stepped on.

    Pros
    Cons
    • Some dogs may ingest nylon bone
    • Owners may step on sharp nylon bone pieces

    3. Pawstruck Filled Dog Bones – Premium Choice

    Pawstruck

    With Pawstruck, you’ll get three heartily filled dog bones that will surely keep your aggressive chewer occupied and satisfied. Selected as our premium choice, this variety pack includes three flavors that most dogs enjoy.

    Each high-quality femur bone has been hollowed out and filled with either peanut butter, cheese and bacon, or beef. These bones naturally improve your dog’s dental health as they chew by removing plaque and tartar, allowing for whiter teeth and fresher breath. Be aware, however, as we learned that hardness of these natural bones can crack your dog’s teeth and sharp splintering can occur.

    While these bones are higher priced, you can feel better about your purchase knowing that Pawstruck is a family-owned small company of dog lovers that is committed to providing high-quality products. It only purchases beef products from grass-fed, free-range cattle processed in USDA- and FDA-approved facilities.

    Pros
    • Three flavor options that dogs prefer
    • Naturally removes plaque and tartar
    • High-quality, natural ingredients
    • Family-owned company of dog lovers
    Cons
    • Potential for cracked teeth
    • Bone may splinter into sharp pieces
    • Higher priced

    4. Nylabone Big Dog Chew Bone

    Nylabone

    If you’re looking for a long-lasting, tough, and durable dog bone for your aggressive chewer, you may want to consider the Nylabone Big Chew toy bone. Made of strong nylon, your dog may work on this dog bone for hours.

    This virtually indestructible dog bone engages and entertains your dog with a bone-like shape that has knots on each end to help hold your dog’s interest. Plus, the extensive chewing time, in addition to the bone having raised bristles, helps clean teeth and control plaque and tartar. However, the bone may become too rough and potentially cause injury to your dog’s mouth.

    Take note that this bone should not come apart. If your dog rips it to pieces, you may have an issue with your dog swallowing the pieces, which are not made of natural materials and not intended for consumption.

    Pros
    • Long-lasting and holds dog’s interest
    • Durable and virtually indestructible material
    • Bone-like shape appeals to dogs
    • Improved dental health
    Cons
    • May become rough and cause injury
    • Potential for accidental ingestion
    • Not made of natural materials

    5. Petstages 219 Dogwood Chew Toy

    Petstages

    If your dog likes to chew on sticks, Petstages Dogwood chew toy may be the best alternative. This chew toy closely resembles an actual stick that you may find in your backyard. However, it’s made to provide your dog with a safer option.

    The Petstages Dogwood chew toy incorporates real wood with durable synthetic materials that mimic the taste and texture of real wood. It has a mesquite barbeque flavor to further entice your dog. These stick-shaped chew toys are ideal for retrieval training and interactive play and come in four sizes.

    We found instances that contradict Petstages’s claim that it’s a safer option than real sticks because it’s designed not to splinter or create a mess. We learned that while aggressive chewers tend to readily enjoy working on this chew toy, they can and will rip it to shreds. Since it’s made with synthetic materials, ingesting the pieces can cause stomach issues.

    Pros
    • Resembles an actual stick
    • Taste and texture most dogs enjoy
    • Ideal for retrieval training and play
    • Comes in four sizes
    Cons
    • May splinter and cause a mess
    • Not safe for ingestion
    • Made with synthetic materials

    6. Pet ‘n Shape 19 Beef Bone Dog Treat

    Pet n Shape

    If you’re interested in providing your dog with a natural and digestible treat, you may want to consider Pet ‘n Shape beef bone dog treat. These hollow beef bones are 100% natural and high in protein and do not contain artificial colors, additives, or preservatives. They’re also free of any wheat, corn, or soy.

    These beef bones are made and sourced in the U.S.A. Pet ‘n Safe roasts each bone with care for higher quality and a flavor most dogs prefer. However, these bones do not come with a filling that may further entice your dog. Also, be aware that we learned that some packages had insects living inside the bone.

    With natural bones, splintering and sharp pieces can occur, especially with an aggressive chewer. Although the bones are digestible, the sharp edges can damage to your dog’s mouth, throat, or intestines, as well as injure you if you happen to accidentally step on one.

    Pros
    • 100% natural Ingredients
    • No artificial colors, additives, or preservatives
    • Free of wheat, corn, and soy
    • Made and sourced in the U.S.A.
    • Roasted for quality and flavor
    Cons
    • Does not include a filling
    • May contain insects
    • Splintering and sharp pieces

    7. K9 Connoisseur Dog Chew Bones

    K9 Connoisseur

    Made from free-range, grass-fed cattle raised in the U.S.A., K9 Connoisseur dog bones are marrow-filled beef bones. Because they’re fully natural, you won’t have to worry about synthetic ingredients or allergens. Chewing on natural beef bones has the added benefit of improving your dog’s dental health.

    We found that some dogs lost interest after a brief amount of time with these bones. However, K9 suggests that once your dog has removed the marrow, you can fill the hollow bone with a tempting treat like peanut butter.

    Priced higher than similar products, K9 claims that each bone is hand-inspected for quality assurance. We found that most dog owners are satisfied with the quality. Still, we learned of several occurrences of splintering into sharp pieces, and unfortunately, quality control issues including spoiled or dried-out bones.

    Pros
    • Made from free-range, grass-fed cattle
    • Marrow-filled, all-natural beef bones
    • Improved dental health
    • Can fill hollow bones with your own treat
    Cons
    • Splintering and sharp pieces
    • Dogs lost interest
    • Quality control issues
    • Higher priced

    8. Pet Qwerks DBB3 Dinosaur BarkBone

    Pet Qwerks

    Are you looking for a challenge for your aggressive chewer? You may want to give him a dinosaur bone.

    The Pet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone is an oversized, heavy-duty nylon bone. While no chew toy is completely indestructible, your aggressive chewer may enjoy gnawing on it for a while. We learned that some aggressive chewers did successfully tear it to shreds, but it took them several hours.

    The Dinosaur BarkBone has bacon flavor infused throughout its nylon material, which many dogs seem to enjoy. The extra chewing time and the nylon material helps clean your dog’s teeth and massage their gums.

    Take note that despite it being made of FDA-approved nylon, the materials are synthetic and should not be ingested. If your dog does break off pieces, you’ll need to make sure that they don’t get eaten.

    Pros
    • Oversized and heavy-duty
    • Challenging for aggressive chewers
    • Bacon flavor that most dogs enjoy
    • FDA-approved nylon
    • Helps clean teeth and massage gums
    Cons
    • Made of synthetic materials
    • Not safe for digestion
    • May become ripped to shreds

    9. Jack&Pup Filled Dog Chew Bones

    Jack&Pup

    Ideal as an alternative to marrow-filled bones, Jack&Pup dog bones come in a package of three all-natural bones filled with three flavors: peanut butter, bacon and cheese, and bully sticks.

    While the bones are made from beef shins, which are sourced from grass-fed, free-range cattle that are raised without added hormones or antibiotics, the filling does contain artificial flavors. We found that quite a few dogs did not care for the taste. Also, some fillings appear dried out and crumbly.

    As with all bone products, there are the benefits of cleaner teeth from extensive chewing and the chance that the bone will splinter. While many bones held up well, we learned that the edges could be thinner and break off.

    Pros
    • Bones sourced from grass-fed, free-range cattle
    • Offers benefit of cleaner teeth
    Cons
    • Significant number of dogs did not like filling flavors
    • Some fillings lacked proper texture
    • Bones may splinter on the ends

    10. EcoKind Pet Treats Femur Bone

    EcoKind Pet Treats

    This dog bone is, by far, the largest natural product on our list. The EcoKind Pet Treats is an actual, full-size, uncut femur bone sourced from 100% grass-fed, free-range cattle. This bone is antibiotic-free, hormone-free, and digestible.

    This oversized bone has a meaty, rich, smoked flavor that most dogs prefer. The full length of this femur bone is capped on either end with two large knuckles. Your dog may also enjoy the attached pieces of tendon and meat.

    While more expensive than similar products on our list, we found fewer occurrences of this bone splintering. Plus, the excessive chewing on a natural bone helps improve your dog’s dental health.

    However, we learned that the extra-large and heavy make-up of this bone isn’t well-suited for medium to small dogs. A few dog owners reported receiving bones that arrived broken. Also, some dogs experienced severe stomach upset after chewing on it for only a few hours.

    Pros
    • Sourced from grass-fed, free-range cattle
    • Flavor and texture that most dogs prefer
    • Improves dental health
    Cons
    • More expensive than similar products
    • Too large and heavy for smaller dogs
    • Quality control issues with broken bones
    • May cause severe stomach upset

    Conclusion:

    We hope that after reading through our reviews, you’ve found a dog bone that will keep your aggressive chewer content and occupied. From natural beef bones to synthetic products, there’s plenty of options to challenge your dog’s chewing skills.

    Our top pick, Natural Farm Dog Chew Bones offers premium ingredients and ideal consistency for aggressive chewers. For the best value, you may want to consider Hartz Chew ‘n Clean Dog Chew Toy, which combines a durable nylon chew toy and a tasty dog treat in one product. Finally, we selected Pawstruck Filled Dog Bones as our premium choice for its high-quality bones and fillings that nearly every dog enjoys.

    With the right dog bone, you can rest easy knowing that your aggressive chewer has a positive way to exercise their jaws and even clean their teeth in the process.