Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

8 Best Dog Treat Makers – 2024 Reviews & Top Picks  

Brooke Bundy

By Brooke Bundy

Yorkshire Terrier dog eats a treat

Prices on pre-made food are through the roof. It’s sometimes hard to justify buying a bag of dog treats that costs more than our lunch! Not to mention, the slew of pet food recalls over the last few years makes us feel a little uneasy about some commercial treats. Baking your dog’s treats at home gives you greater control over the quality and allows you to customize the ingredients to their dietary needs and preferences.

But let’s be real: no one wants to stand over a hot stove all day. Most days we’re doing good if we cook a homemade meal for ourselves. Dog treat makers are a huge time saver that allows you to quickly whip up a small batch of snacks for your pup while you multitask. A dog treat maker can be as simple as a silicone mold that you pop in the freezer for some yummy dog popsicles, or as sophisticated as a miniature shaved ice machine. We’ve rounded up the best dog treat makers this year, complete with reviews of each one, to help you find the right tool for your pup.

hepper-dog-paw-divider2A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2024

Rating Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
DASH Dog Treat Maker DASH Dog Treat Maker
  • Creates soft baked treats
  • Approximate 10 minute cook time
  • Includes a recipe booklet
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Stainless Steel Metal Dog Bone Shape Cookie Cutter Set Stainless Steel Metal Dog Bone Shape Cookie Cutter Set
  • Three different sized cookie cutters
  • Stainless steel
  • Affordable
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Bake-A-Bone The Original Dog Treat Maker Bake-A-Bone The Original Dog Treat Maker
  • Perfect for dogs who prefer crunchy bones
  • Non-stick surface holds 4 bones
  • Includes a recipe booklet
  • Le Dogue Dog Treat Molds Silicone Le Dogue Dog Treat Molds Silicone
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Heat safe up to 450°F
  • BPA-free silicone
  • GoSports Pets PupsCream Parlor Non-Slip Frozen Dog Treat GoSports Pets PupsCream Parlor Non-Slip Frozen Dog Treat
  • Includes 6 reusable treat molds and bone-shaped treat holder
  • Dishwasher safe molds
  • Standard sized holder accommodates store-bought pup cups
  • The 8 Best Dog Treat Makers 

    1. DASH Dog Treat Maker – Best Overall

    DASH Dog Treat Maker

    Check Price on Chewy

    If you’re familiar with DASH products, you know that they specialize in miniature appliances that perform one or two functions extremely well. The DASH Dog Treat Maker is no exception. As our choice for the best overall dog treat maker, it excels in creating soft-baked treats that come out perfectly each time. The non-stick mold fits up to eight treats at once, and the included booklet includes several recipes. The approximate cooking time is 10 minutes for each set of eight.

    While the mold is non-stick, we recommend applying a light coat of olive oil before you begin to prevent the bones from sticking and burning. The treats have a soft-baked texture similar to a waffle. If you want a crunchy treat, you’ll need to pop them in the oven for a few minutes at a high temperature or find a more appropriate product.

    Pros
    • Non-stick cooking surface with 8 bones
    • Creates soft baked treats
    • Approximate 10 minute cook time
    • Includes a recipe booklet

    Cons
    • Doesn’t produce a crunchy treat


    2. Stainless Steel Metal Dog Bone Shape Cookie Cutter Set – Best Value

    Stainless Steel Metal Dog Bone Shape Cookie Cutter Set

    If you have an oven, the Stainless Steel Metal Dog Bone Shape Cookie Cutter Set may be the most cost-efficient choice. Each cookie cutter in the 3-piece set is a different size, which is convenient if you have more than one dog. Our choice for the best dog treat maker for the money is incredibly budget-friendly while still being built to last a long time. However, it’s hand-wash only, so you’ll need to budget a couple more minutes for clean-up. There isn’t a recipe booklet, but there are plenty out there on the internet for when you want to start baking.

    Pros
    • Three different sized cookie cutters
    • Stainless steel
    • Affordable

    Cons
    • Hand-wash only
    • Requires an oven
    • No recipe booklet


    3. Bake-A-Bone The Original Dog Treat Maker – Premium Choice

    Bake-A-Bone The Original Dog Treat Maker

    If your dog likes to crunch on baked bones, the Bake-A-Bone Original Dog Treat Maker is the best way to make that happen. As our premium choice, it’s a little pricey compared to the others on our list, but the quality seems worth it. The non-stick surface is easy to clean and holds 4 large bones. The treat maker includes a recipe booklet, but usually the recipes give instructions to make around 26 treats. Since the treat maker only holds 4 bones, which take about 10 minutes to bake, it can be a little time consuming to make an entire batch.

    We think this tool is perfect if you have a large dog and about an hour to make treats. The bones are too big for a tiny dog, and you’d have to do some math to figure out the ingredients for a partial batch, so a different option is probably best for a small breed or quick snack.

    Pros
    • Perfect for dogs who prefer crunchy bones
    • Non-stick surface holds 4 bones
    • Includes a recipe booklet

    Cons
    • Limited spots in the mold
    • Recipes are usually for a large batch
    • Expensive


    4. Le Dogue Dog Treat Molds Silicone

    Le Dogue Dog Treat Molds Silicone

    Le Dogue Dog Treat Molds are crafted from BPA-silicone. The non-stick material lets your treats pop out for easy storage and clean-up. Heat resistant up to 450°F and safe for the microwave, freezer, and dishwasher, this tool can mold virtually any type of treat. The free recipe booklet gives you instructions on how to make treats, or you can create your own recipe. Since the molds are made from flexible silicone, you may need to use a cookie sheet or other material to stabilize them when moving them into the freezer or oven. The 2-piece set includes one mold featuring paws and one mold with bones.

    Pros
    • Versatile for baked or frozen treats
    • Free recipe booklet
    • Dishwasher safe
    • Heat safe up to 450°F
    • BPA-free silicone

    Cons
    • May require using a cookie sheet underneath for support


    5. GoSports Pets Non-Slip Frozen Dog Treat & Ice Cream Holder

    GoSports Pets PupsCream Parlor Non-Slip Frozen Dog Treat & Ice Cream Holder

    Dog ice cream is a nutritious way for your pup to cool off, but the single-serve cartons can be pricey at the pet store and messy to eat at home. We like how the GoSports Pets Non-Slip Frozen Dog Treat & Ice Cream Holder gives you the option to prepare ice cream at home with the six reusable molds and also provides a secure way for your dog to eat a store-bought treat. The bone-shaped treat holder accommodates most commercial brands of dog ice cream, and fits the included molds. This is a great option for messy dogs who may slurp their frozen treats on the rug. The molds are dishwasher safe, which makes them easy to reuse. The treat holder may not be dishwasher safe since the materials aren’t specified, so we recommend cleaning it with soap and water.

    Pros
    • Includes 6 reusable treat molds and bone-shaped treat holder
    • Dishwasher safe molds
    • Standard sized holder accommodates store-bought pup cups

    Cons
    • Treat holder may or may not be dishwasher safe


    6. Babycakes Multi-Treat Baker

    Babycakes Multi-Treat Baker

    While novelty appliances look cute, sometimes they’re not the most practical option if you have limited counter space. The Babycakes Multi-Treat Baker takes the place of several tools, including muffin tins and Bundt cake pans. The non-stick cake pop mold is the perfect size for a baked dog treat. Plus, since it holds a dozen, you can cook more treats at once than you can with most treat makers labeled specifically for our canine friends. The three non-stick molds are easily cleaned with soap and water. Since it doesn’t specify whether it’s dishwasher safe, we’d advise you to only hand wash the plates and apply a light coat of oil afterwards to prevent sticking.

    Pros
    • Three removable non-stick molds
    • Cake pop mold is the perfect size for dog treats
    • Saves space and time since it’s multi-purpose

    Cons
    • Hand-wash only


    7. Nostalgia Snow Cone Shaved Ice Machine

    Nostalgia Snow Cone Shaved Ice Machine

    While not marketed towards pet parents, the Nostalgia Snow Cone Shaved Ice Machine lets you customize a dairy-free frozen treat for your pup. The red retro design gives a vintage flair while taking up a minimal amount of space to suit modern lifestyles. This product comes with sugary flavored syrups, but these are not safe for your dog. You’ll need to flavor your dog’s snow cone with broth or give them plain shaved ice instead. Save the simple syrups for your own snack.

    Pros
    • Cute vintage style
    • Takes up minimal space
    • Ideal for dogs who need a dairy-free treat

    Cons
    • Included syrups aren’t safe for dogs


    8. OSTBA Food Dehydrator Adjustable Temperature & Timer

    OSTBA Food Dehydrator Machine Adjustable Temperature & 72H Timer

    Jerky treats, dehydrated blueberries, and other healthy snacks all become possible for pennies with the OSTBA Food Dehydrator. Bags of dried dog treats are expensive and often loaded with preservatives. Making your own treats at home is a cost-cutting option that’s usually better for them. This device features a temperature range between 95℉ to 160℉ and a timer that goes up to 72 hours before it automatically shuts off. The five trays allow you to dehydrate a large batch at once, which lowers energy costs. Plus, they’re dishwasher safe for easy clean-up.

    This product is available with electronic or knob controls to suit your preferences.  Our favorite thing about the OSTBA Food Dehydrator is the fact that you can use it for virtually anything, including your own snacks or emergency food ration stock. Its compact size is great for our purposes and small spaces but may not be big enough to make extra-large batches.

    Pros
    • Healthier and less expensive than commercial dehydrated dog treats
    • Timer goes up to 72 hours before automatic shut off
    • Five dishwasher-safe trays

    Cons
    • Compact size may be too small for extra-large batches

    hepper-dog-paw-divider 5

    Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Dog Treat Maker

    Deciding which treat maker is best for you boils down to your dog’s preferences. Most of the options on our list excel at one type of treat, such as a soft-baked cookie or shaved ice cone. Silicone molds are the most versatile tool because they work in the oven, freezer, or microwave, but you’ll still need the appliances required to make the treats. If you’re looking for an all-in-one treat maker, you might try to find a device that includes the molds and a way to bake the treats, such as the DASH Dog Treat Maker.

    Time and space are other considerations. Novelty appliances are a tempting purchase, but many of us don’t have the storage space for multiple kitchen tools. Finding a multi-purpose tool such as the OSTBA Food Dehydrator may be a more practical purchase since you can also use it to make human snacks. Many novelty appliances also specialize in small batches as opposed to making things in bulk. If you want to quickly make and store dozens of treats to save for later, you’ll be better off purchasing larger molds such as the ones by Le Dogue or use cookie cutters to make multiple batches of baked goods.

    cocker spaniel dog getting treat
    Image Credit: Natalia Bostan, Shutterstock

    hepper-dog-paw-divider 3

    Conclusion

    The DASH Dog Treat Maker was our best overall choice to quickly make batches of soft-baked dog treats. If you’re on a tight budget, you might like our best value choice, the Stainless Steel Metal Cookie Cutter Set. Of course, you’ll still need an oven or some way to cook the treats you make, but buying cutters instead of treat makers is the most low-cost option that doesn’t take up much space. The Bake-A-Bone Original Dog Treat Maker is our premium choice that provides a satisfying crunchy bone mimicking store-bought milk bones. Further down the list, you’ll also see options suited for frozen snacks such as shaved ice and homemade doggie ice cream. With these reviews of eight top products to choose from, we hope you’ll find an option on our list to suit any way your dog likes to snack.

    See Also: 


    Featured Image Credit: Valerie Nik, Shutterstock

    Related Articles

    Further Reading

    Vet Articles

    Latest Vet Answers

    The latest veterinarians' answers to questions from our database