Best Collar for German Shepherds – Reviews & Top Picks 2020

Last Updated:

PET ARTIST Genuine Leather Dog Collar for Walking

Intelligent and protective, German shepherds are the second-most popular dog breed in America. They’re also large and strong, so whether you’re working on training or just taking a daily walk, you’ll need a sturdy, well-designed collar. But there are quite a few models available, so which will work best?

We’re here to help you shop for the perfect collar. We’ve researched for you, testing all of the biggest brands and putting together this list of the 10 best collars for German shepherds available in 2020. For each model, we’ve written a detailed review, looking closely at the price, material, attachment options, overall design, and warranty so you can easily compare. And if you’d like to know more about the features that make a collar great, take a look at our buyer’s guide.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

ModelPriceMaterialEditor Rating
PET ARTIST Genuine Leather
PET ARTIST(Best Overall)

Check Price
Leather4.85/5
EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER Military
EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER(Best Value)

Check Price
Nylon4.70/5
KONG Comfort Neoprene
KONG(Premium Choice)

Check Price
Neoprene4.65/5
Blueberry Pet 3M Reflective
Blueberry Pet

Check Price
Neoprene4.40/5
OneTigris Military Adjustable
OneTigris

Check Price
Nylon4.35/5

The 10 Best Collars for German Shepherds

1. PET ARTIST Leather Dog Collar – Best Overall

PET ARTIST

Our top pick is the PET ARTIST Genuine Leather Dog Collar, which is a stylish leather model with a convenient handle and a good warranty.

This 4.8-ounce collar is made of expensive-feeling genuine leather and comes in two sizes. It has anti-rust zinc alloy buckles and a built-in leather handle to help you control your dog. There’s a sturdy D-ring for leash attachment, and the handle is attached with rivets.

Though the price is on the higher end, this collar is very good-looking and comes with a 90-day quality guarantee. We did find that the leather may stretch and the handle may come off with heavy use.

Pros
  • Stylish genuine leather
  • Sold in two sizes
  • Anti-rust zinc alloy buckles
  • Built-in leather handle attached by rivets
  • D-ring leash attachment
  • 90-day quality guarantee
Cons
  • More expensive
  • Leather may stretch
  • Handle may come off

2. EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER Dog Collar – Best Value

EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER

If you’re looking for value, the EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER DG115-COB-01 Dog Collar is the best collar for German shepherds for the money. This low-cost collar is sturdy and effective.

This 4.8-ounce dog collar comes in three sizes and several basic colors. It’s made with two layers of 1000D nylon and has a padded lining. The collar has a double-pin buckle and a metal D-ring for leash attachment. You can choose among five settings, and the collar has a hook and loop panel for patches.

We found this collar strong and effective, though the hardware isn’t quite as durable. The D-ring may come off, and the hardware may rust over time. The company offers a good 90-day warranty, covering replacements and refunds.

Pros
  • Great value with a low price
  • Sturdy, effective design
  • Choice of three sizes and several basic colors
  • Two layers of 1000D nylon and padded lining
  • Double-pin buckle and D-ring
  • Five adjustable settings
  • Hook and loop panel
  • 90-day replacement and refund warranty
Cons
  • Less durable hardware may rust
  • D-ring may come off

3. KONG Neoprene Dog Collar – Premium Choice

KONG

If you have room in your budget, you may be interested in the KONG Neoprene Padded Dog Collar, a pricier padded option with safety features and a nice range of colors.

This heavier 11.4-ounce collar comes in three attractive colors and several sizes. It’s made of comfortable, padded neoprene that’s easy to wipe clean. Stiff and sturdy, this collar has reflective piping to keep your dog safe at night. There’s also a separate loop for ID tags.

Overall, we found this collar well-built, though the metal clasp isn’t as durable and the reflective coating wears off fairly quickly. We also found that the ID loop wasn’t sewn on well. KONG offers a 60-day satisfaction guarantee.

Pros
  • Good range of colors and sizes
  • Comfortable, padded neoprene
  • Easy to wipe clean
  • Reflective piping for safety
  • Separate loop for ID tags
  • Stiff and sturdy
  • 60-day satisfaction guarantee
Cons
  • More expensive and heavier
  • Less durable metal clasp
  • Reflective coating wears off quickly
  • ID loop isn’t well-attached

See the top brushes for German Shepherds here!


4. Blueberry Pet Neoprene Dog Collars

Blueberry Pet

The Blueberry Pet Neoprene Padded Dog Collar has a bold, distinctive pattern and comfortable padding but is also less durable overall.

This low-cost collar, which weighs only 2.9 ounces, is brightly colored, with a choice of paisley flower patterns. The collar has neoprene padding, eco-friendly plastic buckles, and a chrome-plated D-ring for leash attachment. There’s also a separate loop for ID tags.

We found this collar easy to clean and fast-drying. However, the collar may stretch out with use, making it less dependable, and the ID loop isn’t very sturdy. The plastic buckles also have a cheaper feel, and there isn’t a warranty.

Pros
  • Choice of distinctive paisley patterns
  • Lightweight and low-cost
  • Neoprene padding
  • Easy to clean and dries quickly
  • Eco-friendly plastic buckles
  • Chrome-plated D-ring for leashes
  • Separate loop for ID tags
Cons
  • May stretch with use
  • Less sturdy ID loop
  • Plastic buckles feel cheaper
  • No warranty

5. OneTigris Military Adjustable Dog Collar

OneTigris

The OneTigris Military Adjustable Dog Collar is another low-cost option with a sturdy buckle and plenty of padding. It’s not very durable overall and may be rough on your German shepherd’s skin.

This 5.29-ounce collar comes in three sizes and several basic colors. It’s made of nylon and has inner padding to keep your dog comfortable. If you’d like to attach a patch, there’s a convenient hook and loop panel. The buckle and D-ring are both made of sturdy metal, and the collar offers five adjustable settings.

When we tested this collar, we found that the metal rusted easily and the nylon fabric could be too harsh for dog skin. The metal rivets also fall out fairly quickly, and the D-ring may tear through the fabric with heavy use. OneTigris doesn’t offer a warranty beyond Amazon’s 30-day return policy.

Pros
  • Inexpensive
  • Choice of three sizes and several colors
  • Nylon with inner padding
  • Hook and loop panel
  • Metal buckle and D-ring
  • Five adjustable settings
Cons
  • No warranty
  • Metal hardware may rust
  • Nylon may be harsh on skin
  • Metal rivets and D-ring aren’t well-attached

6. Mighty Paw Leather Training Collar

Mighty Paw

Another inexpensive option is the Mighty Paw Leather Training Collar, which is a leather model with a limited cinch. Though it’s stylish, this collar doesn’t work particularly well.

This 5.6-ounce collar comes in three sizes and is effective on strong dogs. It’s made of leather and includes a stainless steel limited cinch chain, which tightens without choking, allowing you to train your dog without hurting it.

We found that this collar wasn’t especially durable, with leather that might stretch or break under pressure and metal hardware that tended to rust. Mighty Paw offers a 90-day 100% satisfaction guarantee.

Pros
  • Low-cost and stylish
  • Leather with a stainless steel limited cinch chain
  • Choice of three sizes
  • Effective with strong dogs
  • 90-day 100% satisfaction guarantee
Cons
  • Not very durable
  • Leather may stretch or break
  • Metal hardware may rust

7. Taglory Genuine Leather Dog Collars

Taglory

The Taglory 01 Genuine Leather Dog Collar is a low-cost, lightweight leather option with a strong smell and low-quality hardware.

This light 4.2-ounce collar comes in multiple sizes and a choice of black or brown vegetable-tanned genuine leather. You can pay extra to have your dog’s name engraved. The metal hardware is brass-colored and includes an alloy D-ring and an extra ring for ID tags. The collar also features handmade stitching and multiple rivets.

We found this collar to have a strong, unappealing chemical smell. The brass coating on the hardware rubs off quickly, and the low-quality rivets fall out easily. We also found that the D-ring and buckle were prone to breaking. Taglory offers a good 60-day warranty covering unconditional returns.

Pros
  • Low-cost and lightweight
  • Choice of multiple sizes and colors
  • Vegetable-tanned genuine leather
  • Can pay extra for customization
  • Handmade stitching
  • Alloy D-ring, ID ring, and rivets
  • 60-day warranty with unconditional returns
Cons
  • Strong chemical smell
  • Brass hardware coating rubs off
  • Low-quality metal hardware

8. Moonpet Soft Leather Dog Collar

Moonpet

Moonpet’s Soft Padded Genuine Leather Dog Collar is moderately-priced and made of genuine leather but doesn’t feel very well-made and may not be strong enough for your German shepherd.

This 6.4-ounce collar comes in three sizes and several two-tone leather colors. You can pay extra to have your dog’s name stamped into the leather. This collar comes with a large brass D-ring but no extra ID loop.

We found this collar to have a strong chemical smell. It’s stylish and nicely-designed but not particularly well-built, with stitching that quickly comes undone and layers that separate easily. The stamped custom names also wear off fairly quickly. Moonpet offers a satisfaction guarantee.

Pros
  • Reasonably-priced and fairly lightweight
  • Choice of three sizes and several two-tone colors
  • Stylish with genuine leather
  • Can extra pay for customization
  • Large brass D-ring
  • Satisfaction guarantee
Cons
  • Strong chemical smell
  • Stitching may come undone
  • Layers may separate
  • Stamped names wear off

9. Herm Sprenger Steel Prong Collar

Herm Sprenger

The Herm Sprenger PSI-50057 Steel Prong Collar is a pricey metal prong model that’s specifically designed for training. It has a somewhat cheap feel and isn’t very effective.

This four-ounce collar features five links and 10 3.2-millimeter stainless steel prongs. The prongs have beveled, polished ends, and you can remove or purchase additional links to adjust the collar size. The collar features a breakaway snap buckle and a sturdy D-ring for leash attachment.

This collar doesn’t feel very well-made, and without a cinch, it’s not a very effective training aid. Herm Sprenger doesn’t offer a warranty.

Pros
  • Lightweight
  • Black stainless steel
  • Includes five links and 10 3.2-millimeter prongs
  • Designed to help train strong dogs
  • Beveled, polish prongs
  • Breakaway snap buckle and D-ring
Cons
  • Feels somewhat cheap
  • Doesn’t have a cinch
  • Not very effective
  • No warranty
  • More expensive

10. Diezel Pet Products Dog Collars

Diezel Pet Products

Our least favorite model is the Diezel Pet Products Dog Collar, a nylon option with lower-quality hardware and a high price.

This 7.2-ounce collar comes in three colors and two sizes. It’s two inches wide and made of waterproof nylon. The collar has a two-pin metal buckle and 10 inches of hook and loop paneling. The package includes an American flag hook and loop patch.

We found this model to have less durable metal components like the buckle. It runs small, so you may want to read the measurements carefully, and the collar isn’t very durable overall. It’s also a bit more expensive than its limited functionality suggests. Diezel doesn’t offer a warranty.

Pros
  • Waterproof nylon
  • Fairly lightweight
  • Choice of three colors and two sizes
  • Two-pin metal buckle
  • 10 inches of hook and loop paneling
  • Includes an American flag patch
Cons
  • Less durable metal hardware
  • Runs small
  • Doesn’t feel durable overall
  • More expensive
  • No warranty

Buyer’s Guide

You’ve taken a look at our favorite dog collars for German shepherds, but have you decided which to buy? If you’re still on the fence or curious about the available features, keep reading for our quick guide to your options.

Material

You have three main options when it comes to dog collar materials: leather, fabric, and metal. Leather collars have a more expensive feel but may stretch or wear out over time. Fabric collars, often made of nylon or neoprene, are sturdy and generally easy to clean. These collars don’t feel as high-end but are often padded. Keep in mind that nylon may be rough on your dog’s skin.

The third type, metal collars, are designed to be worn only while training. These stainless steel models have prongs that will dig gently into your dog’s neck when you pull the leash tight. If you choose a pronged metal model, you’ll probably want to pick one with polished tips that won’t be too sharp.

Hardware is another consideration. Leather and fabric dog collars are typically held together by metal hardware like buckles and rivets. These can be made of zinc alloy, brass, or stainless steel. To ensure that you’ll get plenty of use out of your collar, you’ll want to make sure your hardware is sturdy enough to withstand heavy use.

Waterproofing

Does your German shepherd like to swim or walk in the rain? You may want a collar that can handle water. Depending on the type of collar you prefer, this might mean well-oiled leather, nylon coated in waterproofing, or stainless steel, anti-rust metal. You may want to pay particular attention to your chosen model’s hardware, as lower-quality metals may rust easily.

Hardware

Which pieces of hardware are necessary, and which are convenient but optional? Dog collars generally have buckles and D-rings. A sturdy buckle will keep your dog’s collar securely fastened around its neck. If you’re safety-oriented, you may want to choose a model with a breakaway buckle, which will come apart if the collar gets caught, preventing your dog from suffocating or becoming stuck.

The D-ring is a metal loop that you can attach ID tags and a leash to. You’ll want this ring to be well-attached so your dog won’t lose its ID and registration tags or become disconnected from its leash. Being well-attached means that the D-ring is made of sturdy metal that won’t come apart under pressure, but it also means that the collar material is strong enough to hold the D-ring.

Dog collars may also have an extra ring that you can use exclusively for ID tags. This can be convenient, keeping the tags and leash attachment separate and giving you more flexibility.

Warranties

Would you like the security of a good warranty? Our three favorite models all offer warranties covering two or three months. Others cover only one month or don’t come with a warranty at all. If warranties matter to you, you’ll probably want to pay attention to what each covers, as some offer limited coverage, while others allow for unconditional returns.

Conclusion

Our top pick is the PET ARTIST Genuine Leather Dog Collar, which is a fairly-priced, stylish leather option with high-quality metal hardware and a convenient handle. Are you shopping on a budget? You may want to try the EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER DG115-COB-01 Dog Collar, a low-cost, well-built nylon model with a great warranty and a sturdy design. Would you prefer something high-end? Take a look at the KONG Neoprene Padded Dog Collar, a pricey but sturdy nylon option that’s easy to clean and has added safety features.

Your German shepherd deserves a sturdy, nicely-designed collar that will look good and work well. You deserve to quickly find a great model without spending too much time or money. That’s where we come in, with this list of 2020’s 10 best collars for German shepherds, which comes complete with comprehensive reviews and a quick feature guide. You’ll have a great collar before you know it!


By Kate MacDonnell

Featured image credit: PET ARTIST Genuine Leather Dog Collar for Walking, Amazon