Excessive barking is one of the most popular noise complaints reported and is considered an annoyance to others. While barking and “talking” dogs may be cute to some, it can become a serious lifelong habit if it’s not corrected. Although positive reinforcement training may solve some of the incessant barking, your dog will probably go back to the excessive barking whenever you’re not home.
It can be incredibly hard to train a dog not to bark, especially for high-energy, hunting dogs like Labrador Retrievers. For this reason, many dog owners and hunters turn to bark collars to aid in the training process. Though bark and stim-shock collars sound excessive or harsh, they can be extremely effective when used correctly. If you have a loud-mouthed Lab at home or you’re starting a new pup in the hunting field, here are 7 Best Bark Collars for Labs and their reviews:
A Quick Comparison of our Favorites
The 6 Best Bark Collars for Labs — Reviews 2020
1. DogRook Bark Collar — Best Overall
The DogRook Bark Collar is a shock-free barking collar designed to correct your lab’s barking as it happens. It uses a humane system of correction that consists of sounds and vibration to deter the barking, instead of relying on shocking and other negative reinforcement training techniques.
This bark correcting collar comes with a rechargeable battery that holds a 20-day lifespan per each charge, so you won’t have to charge it every other night. Another great feature to mention is the water-resistant design and tough nylon collar, making it ideal for dogs that go outdoors. It’s safe to use on any dog between 10 to 110 pounds, which safely covers the average weight range of Labradors.
This model is also customizable and comes with two detachable covers in blue and orange, so you can personalize it to your taste. One issue we do have is that may not be stronger for bigger Labs, even though it does have 7 settings. Otherwise, we highly recommend trying the DogRook Bark Collar if you’re looking for the best overall bark collar for labs.
2. PETKING Anti Bark Dog Collar — Best Value
PETKING Anti Bark Dog Collar is a small barking collar with a sleek and lightweight design. It uses a shock-free correction to stop your lab from barking with a series of sounds or vibrations, teaching your dog to refrain from barking safely.
This model is programmed with 7 adjustable levels of vibration sensitivity, which is important to look for in a barking collar. It also comes with plastic covers to go over the barking unit prongs, keeping your dog’s neck comfortable and safe during use.
It’s also a less expensive collar than other models, especially the premium-brand bark collars. However, it may not save you money in the long run since it requires batteries, so it’s doesn’t have a rechargeable unit. Another potential issue is that it may turn on and accidentally correct your lab from another dog barking, which can cause serious confusion and possible behavioral issues.
For those reasons, we kept it from being our #1 spot. Aside from these two concerns, we find the PETKING Anti Bark Dog Collar to be the best value bark collar for labs for the money.
Dogtra YS600 Rechargeable No Bark Collar is a premium anti-barking collar for dogs over 35lbs, including Labradors. The correction vibration and stim-shock to prevent your dog barking, with a low-stim stock if your lab ignores the vibration to many times. It comes with 10 different levels of stim-shock sensitivity, so you can adjust it to your dog’s comfort level.
This model is fully waterproof design, so it’s great for dogs that are active outdoors and in the field for hunting. The best feature of this model is the ultrasensitive bark sensor that blocks outdoor noises and other dogs barking, which prevents accidental shocks to your dog.
This model is on the expensive side, so it may not be the best option if you’re on a budget or don’t need a waterproof model. It’s also slightly bulky in design compared to our Top 2 models, which is why we kept it from being in our Top 2 spots. However, if you’re looking for a premium bark collar, the Dogtra YS600 Rechargeable No Bark Collar is worth the investment.
4. NPS No Shock Bark Collar
The NPS No-Shock Bark Collar is a basic shock-free bark correction collar that comes in either black or orange. It’ designed with a no-shock sound and vibration system to correct unwanted barking without the use of a stim-shock. This model is different than some models in that it uses a progressive cycle of 7 vibration strengths to correct barking, rather than one set vibration level. It’s also designed to be lightweight and waterproof, which is good for dogs that are outdoors often.
However, there are a few notable concerns that need to be mentioned. The smallest issue is with the lack of a rechargeable battery, so you’ll have to spend additional money on batteries. The second issue is that the vibration may not be strong enough for stubborn or bigger-sized labs, making the collar useless as a bark deterrent. Lastly, it may be triggered by other dogs barking or other outdoor noises, so this model is only suitable for quiet households with only one dog.
5. PetYeah Dog Anti Bark Collar
The PetYeah Dog Anti Bark Collar is an anti-bark collar that uses sounds, vibration, and shocks to prevent unwanted barking. It’s programmed with two separate modes that include a shock-free option, so you can choose a mode based on your dog’s trainability.
This model comes with silicone caps for the prongs, which makes it more comfortable on your lab’s neck where the contact points meet. It’s attached to an adjustable nylon snap collar, making it easy to size appropriately to your dog’s neck. While this model is advertised as waterproof, it tends to malfunction in inclement weather and can stop working when wet.
Another issue is that it only comes with 5 levels of stim-shock, which can be harsher due to fewer options for sensitivity. This collar’s battery lifespan is also shorter than most rechargeable units, with a lifespan of fewer than 10 days. We recommend trying one of our Top 3 picks for better results first.
6. SparklyPets Rechargeable Bark Collar
The SparklyPets Rechargeable Bark Collar is an anti-bark collar programmed with sound, vibration, and shock correction. It comes with two training modes with a shock option for one, giving you the choice of a training method that suits your Lab. It also comes with a rechargeable battery that has a 15-day lifespan, which is decent compared to other rechargeable models.
However, this anti-bark collar seems to have the least accurate bark sensor, sometimes getting triggered by other dogs barking nearby or outside noises that sound similar to barking. Another potential problem is with the limited range of stim-shock sensitivity, with only 5 levels to choose from. This collar may have a lag in correction, which can actually train your dog to bark even more.
It’s also not suitable for outdoor use in the rain or inclement weather, which can be a dealbreaker for some lab owners. We recommend trying the Dogtra for better correcting accuracy and waterproof design.
Labrador Retrievers are one of the most recognizable dog breeds, often the choice for families looking for an active and loyal pet. These high-energy dogs are not only athletic but are eager in training and make excellent service dogs. Most lab owners stick to the breed, falling in love with the breed’s loyal and affectionate ways.
Size, History & Lineage
Labrador Retrievers are medium-to-large dogs that come from England but were introduced to Labrador, Canada, by way of trading ships. The lineage can be traced back to the 1830s, with the breed’s popularity growing since. Today, Labs are considered the most popular breed in the United States, even compared to Golden Retrievers.
These large gun dogs have different lineages that change some of their appearances, depending on if the lines are for companionship or working. Typically, Labrador males stand at around 22-24 inches tall and females measure around 21-23 inches tall. Male Labs weigh around 60 to 80 pounds and females weigh around 55 to 75 pounds.
Personality & Lifestyle
Labradors are high in energy and therefore require hours of exercise daily, preferably with access to water. Their coats are naturally water-resistant, so they can retain heat while swimming in cold temperatures. Because labs tend to have a lot of energy, they can form an excessive barking habit if they’re not trained and exercised properly.
Shock vs. No-Shock
The shock collar has created quite the heated debate amongst the dog community, considered an inhumane and cruel form of training. However, some dog owners swear by their shock collars and take great care not to use them incorrectly. The important thing about shock collars is to introduce them to your dog, so your dog fully and completely understands what is expected when the collar is being used.
If your dog responds well to vocal commands, your lab may do well with a no-shock barking collar that relies on sounds and vibrations instead of a shock. Otherwise, barking collars that have a stim-shock option can help train your dog to bark less. Regardless of which route you go, always ensure that the stim-shock or vibration is on a level that your lab can safely tolerate.
After carefully reviewing and comparing each bark collar, the winner of Best Overall goes to the DogRook Bark Collar. It uses a shock-free bark correction and has a water-resistant design to stay working in the rain. The winner of Best Value goes to the PETKING Anti Bark Dog Collar. It has all the bells and whistles of most bark collars at an affordable price.
We looked for high-quality bark collars with your dog’s safety in mind. Hopefully, our guide will help you find the right bark collar for your lab. With correct use and training, anti-barking collars can be an effective tool for your boisterous lab. Before using the bark collar, we recommend finding a professional dog trainer to help you properly introduce it to your dog.
Featured Image Credit: PetKing Premium, Amazon
Emily started this blog out of pure passion. She LOVES her 3 dogs; Chew Barka, Cooper & Nelson, and spends countless hours every day playing with them.
When she’s not nerding out on dogs, you’ll find her on a snowboard or in the kitchen baking chocolate brownies.
She’s been featured in PetAware, Dogtime, and ModernDog.
- A Quick Comparison of our Favorites
- The 6 Best Bark Collars for Labs — Reviews 2020
- Buyer’s Guide
- About Labradors
- Shock vs. No-Shock