Authority Grain-Free Dog Food Review: Recalls, Pros & Cons

Last Updated:

authority dog food review

Our Final Verdict

We give Authority Grain-Free dog food a rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars.

Introduction

The Authority brand was started by the pet store chain PetSmart. It was created to give dog owners an affordable way to give their pups healthy, natural food.

Each bag proudly claims to be made in the USA, but there’s no information offered as to where, exactly, it’s made. The company is headquartered in Phoenix, Arizona, but it’s unlikely that the food is made there; instead, it’s likely manufactured in processing plants across the country.

Divider 1

At a Glance: The Best Authority Grain-Free Dog Food Recipes

Authority Dog FoodPriceFlavorSizes Available
Skin, Coat & Digestive Health Support
Authority Skin, Coat & Digestive Health Fish & Potato Formula(Our Favorite)

Check Price
Fish & Potato 12 lbs
21 lbs
All Life Stages
Authority Turkey, Pea, Duck & Salmon Formula

Check Price
Turkey, Pea, Duck & Salmon30 lbs
Everyday Health Large Breed
Authority Chicken & Pea Formula Large Breed

Check Price
Chicken & Pea30 lbs
Everyday Health
Authority Grain-Free Chicken & Pea Formula

Check Price
Chicken & Pea 15 lbs
30 lbs
Everyday Health Small Breed
Authority Chicken & Pea Formula Small Breed

Check Price
Chicken & Pea 5 lbs
15 lbs
30 lbs

Authority Grain-Free Dog Food Reviewed

Who makes Authority Grain-Free and where is it produced?

Authority Grain-Free is made by PetSmart, a giant pet store chain. It’s not known for certain where the food is produced, but the packaging proudly states that it’s made in the USA.

Which Types of Dogs is Authority Grain-Free Best Suited For?

This food is ideal for animals with allergies or sensitive stomachs, as it omits grains, which are notorious for causing digestive issues.

It’s also suitable for animals that are trying to shed a few pounds, as grains are generally filled with empty calories.

Our Favorite Deal Right Now
Chewy logo

30% OFF at Chewy.com

+ FREE Shipping on Dog Food and Supplies

How to redeem this offer

Which Types of Dogs Might Do Better with a Different Brand?

With the exception of their High-Performance foods (of which there aren’t many), most of these don’t have the protein necessary to fuel active dogs, such as working pups.

For them, we’d recommend something like Bully Max High Performance Super Premium Dog Food.

divider 9

Discussion of the Primary Ingredients

The primary ingredient is deboned whitefish, which is low in calories, high in protein, and packed with omega fatty acids. It’s also filled with important nutrients like niacin, phosphorus, and selenium.

There’s also fish meal inside, which is kind of a mishmash of all the internal organs of various fish. This may not sound appetizing, but your dog should love it, and more importantly it has nutrients that you can’t find anywhere else.

The next two ingredients are dried potatoes and dried sweet potatoes. We like the sweet potatoes, as they’re full of fiber and other important nutrients, but the dried potatoes do little more than add bulk. They’re also a high-glycemic food, so they can cause your pup’s blood sugar to spike.

After that, there’s canola oil. That may seem like a strange ingredient for a dog food, but it’s included because it’s loaded with omega fatty acids. Think of it like a fish oil.

There are a few other ingredients we love — dried kale, for example — and others we could do without (dried egg product, which can act as an allergen). However, most of these are far enough down the list that there’s not enough of them in the food to get worked up over.

Authority Grain-Free Nixes Cheap Fillers

Grains like wheat and corn are often included in dog foods to bulk them up, but they offer little nutritional value. Worse, they’re full of empty calories, and many dogs have problems digesting them.

By going grain-free, this Authority line ensures that just about every calorie is useful, while also increasing the chances that your dog will process the food with ease.

There’s a Heavy Emphasis Placed on Omega Fatty Acids

Omega fatty acids are a wonder food, and it’s easy to see why: they can aid in the development of your dog’s brain, eyes, and immune system, they reduce the risk of heart disease, and they can fight inflammation.

Authority Grain-Free is filled to the brim with these nutrients, as in addition to the fish, it has canola oil and flaxseed meal.

Authority Dog Foods are Specially-Designed to Clean Teeth

The company uses a proprietary processing technique to create their Ora-Shield System, which basically means that their kibble is more abrasive than most other dry foods.

While this may not sound like a good thing, it means that the kibble does a good job of scraping away plaque, tartar, and other gunk from your pup’s teeth and gums. That reduces the risk of periodontal disease later on in life.

View this post on Instagram

Alot of people ask me what we feed our dogs and it has been changed a lot over the last 18 years. For now we are feeding Authority large breed chicken and rice adult to our grown Dogos and pups get Authority chicken and rice puppy. They have been on this for a year now and so far I am happy with the results. My daughter works for Petsmart so she gets a 50% discount to feed her dogs Authority and so far we are happy with the Dogos being on this food. Before Authority they were on Proplan 30/20 sport and although I loved the muscle it put on them it also put staining on their coats from the excess protien and they would loose weight too easily if they went off food for even a few days. Before that is was Diamond until they started using Peas in their food. So only time will tell but so far I like it my puppies have been very healthy and fit and they all seem to be growing up nice and our adults are in great show conditions. Anyone please feel free to comment what you feed your Dogos and why below. #dogo #dogoargentino #debonairdogos #dogosofinstagram #dogfood #feedingyourdog #authoritydogfood #petsmart

A post shared by Debonair Dogos (@sandiegodogoargentino) on

There are Still Quite a Few Potential Allergens Inside

Most grain-free foods are created to reduce the risk of upsetting dogs’ stomachs, and Authority Grain-Free is no exception. That doesn’t mean they eliminated every single potential issue, however.

Many of the recipes include potatoes, which can cause gas. They also use eggs and chicken in some of their flavors, both of which are common irritants.

While it’s impossible to anticipate every single problematic ingredient, it’s surprising to us that they would choose to include foods that are known to cause so many issues.

A Quick Look at Authority Grain-Free Dog Food

Pros
  • Uses no cheap fillers
  • Packed with omega fatty acids
  • Special kibble cleans teeth while dogs eat
Cons
  • Still includes many common allergens
  • Only has an average amount of protein

Recall History

The Authority brand has only been involved in one recall. Along with over 100 other dog food brands, it was part of the great melamine recall of 2007, in which a lethal chemical found in plastics somehow made its way into pet foods.

Thousands of pets were killed from eating tainted food, but we don’t know if Authority was the cause of any of those deaths.

However, the fact that this company has only been part of a single recall is encouraging.

Divider 2

Reviews of the Three Best Authority Grain-Free Dog Food Recipes

Authority’s Grain-Free line has several different recipes to choose from, and in the section below we took a deep dive into three of our favorites:

1. Authority Skin, Coat, & Digestive Health Fish & Potato Formula Grain-Free Adult Dog

Authority Skin, Coat & Digestive Health Fish & Potato Formula

The fish in this food ensures that it’s packed with omega fatty acids, and the company goes one step further by including a generous amount of canola oil. If your primary concern is giving your dog plenty of antioxidants, this kibble will be tough to beat.

There’s a fair amount of fiber as well, thanks to the sweet potatoes and beet pulp. We also like the inclusion of kale, which is jam-packed with just about every nutrient you can think of.

We only have a few minor quibbles with this food. White potatoes are high on the ingredients list, and they don’t bring much to the table, nutritionally-speaking (although they can cause  noxious gas).

Also, dried egg product adds some protein, but many dogs have issues digesting eggs, so that extra meat was probably better left on the factory floor.

Pros
  • Very high amount of omega fatty acids
  • Good amount of fiber from sweet potatoes and beet pulp
  • Kale adds a wide range of nutrients
Cons
  • White potatoes have little nutritional value
  • Many dogs have issues digesting dried egg product

2. Authority Turkey, Pea, Duck, & Salmon Formula Grain-Free & High Performance

Authority Turkey, Pea, Duck & Salmon Formula

Just looking at the name of this food tells you it has a little bit of everything in it. The first ingredient is deboned turkey, then chicken meal, followed by dried peas, turkey meal, and chicken fat.

That’s quite an interesting list of foods.

They’re all very nutritious, though, and packed with protein (the food itself clocks in at about 30%). They tout the salmon on the bag, but it’s low on the list, so we question just how much is in it.

They do add salmon oil, though, so your dog should get plenty of omega fatty acids. We also like the inclusion of flaxseed meal for omega-3s, chicken cartilage for joint support, and beet pulp for fiber.

We could do without the lentils and dried potatoes, though, both of which can spike blood sugar without offering much in return. Also, there’s a lot of salt in this food.

Overall, though, this kibble is denselypacked with nutrients, and should be more than capable of powering the average dog.

Pros
  • High amount of protein
  • Has chicken cartilage for joint support
  • Good amount of fiber
Cons
  • Lentils and potatoes can elevate blood sugar
  • High in salt

3. Authority Chicken & Pea Formula Large Breed Grain-Free Adult

Authority Chicken & Pea Formula Large Breed

Intended for big dogs, this formula is packed with chicken and chicken parts. It has lean chicken, chicken meal, and chicken fat, all of which bring different important nutrients to the table.

The manufacturers clearly realize that bigger dogs must lug around more weight, and therefore put more stress on their joints. That’s why they included dried chicken cartilage, which is rich in glucosamine and chondroitin, two very important nutrients for joint health.

We also appreciate the inclusion of inulin, which helps their gut break down and digest the food they eat. This helps them absorb more nutrients from their food (and hopefully creates less waste for you to pick up).

There’s a slightly below-average amount of protein in here, and more salt than we’d like. Both of those are bad news for bigger dogs, who need lean protein to keep the pounds at bay and low-sodium food to prevent water weight.

Pros
  • Lots of glucosamine and chondroitin for joint health
  • Uses all parts of the chicken
  • Has inulin to aid in digestion
Cons
  • Less protein than we’d like
  • Has lots of salt

What Other Users are Saying

  • HerePup – “Not only are they some of the least expensive foods on the market, but they also have healthy protein sources as the main ingredients.”
  • Dog Food Guru – “Authority dog food is ideal for high-energy dogs, as well as other dogs with health-conscious owners.”
  • Chewy – As pet owners, we always double-check with Chewy reviews from buyers before we buy something. You can read these by clicking here.
Our Favorite Deal Right Now
Chewy logo

30% OFF at Chewy.com

+ FREE Shipping on Dog Food and Supplies

How to redeem this offer

Divider 5

Conclusion

This food is made with healthy ingredients, including lean proteins, foods high in omega fatty acids, and nutrient-rich vegetables. It also eschews cheap fillers like wheat and corn, which are full of empty calories and little else.

The kibble isn’t perfect, as it uses a few questionable ingredients, but overall, you can see how the manufacturer placed an emphasis on healthy foods. If they would swap out some of their dodgy ingredients for nutrient-rich alternatives, this could quickly become one of our favorite brands.

While Authority Grain-Free isn’t quite at the same level as other premium grain-free foods, it’s certainly close, and it manages to be competitive with those brands despite being much less expensive. That makes it an excellent choice for health-conscious pet owners on a tight budget.


Featured image credit: Authority Skin, Coat & Digestive Health Fish & Potato Formula, Chewy